Choosing between the Lull and Nectar mattresses can feel overwhelming when both promise exceptional comfort and value. After extensive research and analysis, we've discovered that while these popular memory foam mattresses share similarities, they cater to distinctly different sleep preferences.
The Nectar offers softer, more contouring support ideal for side sleepers, while the Lull provides firmer, more responsive support perfect for back and stomach sleepers.
This comprehensive comparison breaks down everything you need to know about these two mattress giants, from construction and firmness to pricing and performance, helping you make the best choice for your sleep needs.
Contents
Choose Nectar if you:
Choose Lull if you:
Understanding how each mattress is built reveals why they feel so different despite both being all-foam designs.
The Nectar features a 5-layer design totaling 11-12 inches:
The Lull uses a simpler 3-layer design at 10 inches:
The Nectar's thicker memory foam layers create more pronounced contouring, while Lull's thinner comfort layer and responsive foam provide a more balanced feel with less sinkage.
Firmness ratings significantly impact sleep quality, and these mattresses differ notably in this aspect.
The Nectar rates 6-6.5 out of 10 on the firmness scale, placing it at medium to medium-firm. However, the thick memory foam layers create a softer initial feel that allows for deeper body contouring. This combination provides:
The Lull measures 7-8 out of 10, making it notably firmer than the Nectar. Its construction creates:
For context, if you're considering whether you need additional cushioning, our guide on 2 vs 3 inch mattress toppers can help you understand how thickness affects comfort.
Your preferred sleep position dramatically influences which mattress will serve you better.
Nectar Wins - The thicker memory foam layers provide superior pressure relief at shoulders and hips, essential for side sleepers. The softer feel cradles pressure points without creating painful pressure buildup.
Lull Performance - Many side sleepers find the Lull too firm, potentially causing shoulder and hip discomfort, especially for those under 150 pounds.
Both Perform Well - Average-weight back sleepers (130-230 lbs) typically find good support from either mattress. The choice depends on firmness preference:
Lull Wins - The firmer surface prevents excessive hip sinkage, maintaining proper spinal alignment. Stomach sleepers need firm support to prevent lower back strain.
Nectar Performance - Most stomach sleepers find the Nectar too soft, allowing hips to sink and creating uncomfortable spine curvature.
These factors significantly impact couples and those who utilize the full mattress surface.
Nectar Excels - The thick memory foam layers absorb movement exceptionally well, preventing partner disturbance during the night.
Lull Performance - Good motion isolation but slightly more motion transfer due to the responsive foam layer.
Lull Leads - The firmer construction provides better edge stability for sitting or sleeping near the perimeter.
Nectar Performance - Adequate edge support but noticeable compression when sitting on edges.
Both mattresses incorporate cooling features, but neither excels at temperature control compared to hybrid alternatives.
Nectar Features:
Lull Features:
Despite these features, both mattresses sleep warmer than innerspring or hybrid options. Hot sleepers might want to explore the most comfortable mattresses with better cooling properties.
Pricing varies with frequent sales, but here's the typical range for queen sizes:
Nectar Queen: $799-$1,298 (often on sale around $799) Lull Queen: $779-$1,049 (less frequent sales)
Both brands offer competitive pricing in the online mattress market. For the best deals, consider shopping during major sales events. Our guide on when to buy a mattress reveals optimal purchasing times.
Both mattresses come with:
Avoid these pitfalls when choosing between Lull and Nectar:
Maximize your mattress investment with these expert strategies:
Based on comprehensive analysis, here's when each mattress makes sense:
If neither mattress seems perfect, consider these alternatives:
Both offer lifetime warranties and use quality materials. The Nectar's thicker construction may provide slight durability advantages, but both should last 7-10 years with proper care.
Yes, both the Lull and Nectar are compatible with adjustable bed frames, platform beds, and traditional foundations.
Allow 30-60 days for your body to adjust to either mattress. Initial firmness often softens slightly during this period.
Neither Lull nor Nectar uses fiberglass in their fire barriers, using safer alternatives instead.
Nectar typically works better for couples due to superior motion isolation and broader appeal across sleep positions, though Lull's better edge support maximizes usable surface area.
The choice between Lull and Nectar ultimately depends on your personal sleep preferences and body type. The Nectar's thicker memory foam layers make it ideal for side sleepers seeking pressure relief, while the Lull's firmer, more responsive design better serves back and stomach sleepers.
Both mattresses offer exceptional value with their generous trial periods and warranties. Take advantage of these risk-free trials to ensure your choice delivers the restorative sleep you deserve. Remember, the best mattress is the one that helps you wake up refreshed and pain-free every morning.