Choosing between Brooklyn Bedding and Nectar mattresses can feel overwhelming when both brands promise exceptional comfort and value. The key difference? Brooklyn Bedding offers bouncy hybrid construction with customizable firmness options, while Nectar delivers classic memory foam contouring with a lifetime warranty.
After analyzing thousands of customer reviews and sleep test data, we've discovered that Brooklyn Bedding suits combination sleepers who value responsive support, while Nectar excels for side sleepers seeking pressure relief.
This comprehensive comparison breaks down every crucial factor to help you make the right choice for your sleep needs and budget.
Contents
| Feature | Brooklyn Bedding Signature | Nectar Classic |
| Type | Hybrid (foam + coils) | All-foam |
| Firmness | 3 options: Soft (4), Medium (6), Firm (8) | Medium-firm (6.5) |
| Price (Queen) | $999 | $1,099 |
| Trial Period | 120 nights | 365 nights |
| Warranty | 10 years | Lifetime |
| Best For | All sleep positions, hot sleepers | Side sleepers, memory foam lovers |
The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid stands 12.25 inches tall and combines proprietary foams with individually wrapped coils for balanced support. Starting from the top, you'll find a quilted cotton-polyester cover that adds 1.5 inches of instant comfort.
The comfort system features 1.5 inches of Supreme Response Comfort Foam, delivering adaptive support that responds to your sleeping position. Below that lies 1 inch of Variflex transition foam, which gently cradles your body while preventing excessive sinkage.
The support core contains up to 760 Ascension pocketed coils, each 8 inches tall and individually wrapped to minimize motion transfer. A high-density foam base layer provides structural integrity and prevents sagging over time.
Nectar's 12-inch all-foam design prioritizes contouring comfort through multiple specialized layers. The breathable polyethylene cover incorporates cooling fibers to help regulate temperature throughout the night.
The comfort layers begin with 2 inches of gel-infused memory foam that slowly conforms to your body's curves while dissipating heat. Next comes 3 inches of soft conventional foam serving as a dynamic transition layer, providing gentle support without sacrificing comfort.
The foundation consists of 7 inches of high-density support foam that maintains proper spinal alignment while ensuring long-lasting durability. A shift-resistant lower cover keeps all layers perfectly aligned for consistent performance.
The feel difference between these mattresses stems directly from their construction types. Brooklyn Bedding's hybrid design creates a more balanced, responsive surface that makes repositioning effortless. The coils provide gentle bounce while the foam layers add just enough contouring for pressure relief.
Nectar offers that classic memory foam experience many sleepers love. You'll sink into the surface as the foam slowly molds to your body's shape, creating a cradling sensation that feels like sleeping in a warm embrace. This deeper contouring particularly benefits side sleepers who need extra cushioning at pressure points.
Temperature regulation differs significantly between the two. Brooklyn Bedding's coil system promotes airflow throughout the mattress, helping hot sleepers stay comfortable. While Nectar incorporates gel-infused foam and a breathable cover, the dense foam construction naturally retains more heat than the hybrid alternative.
Both mattresses accommodate back sleepers well, but with different approaches. Brooklyn Bedding's medium option provides balanced support that maintains natural spinal alignment without excessive sinkage. The responsive surface makes it easy to change positions throughout the night.
Nectar's medium-firm feel offers slightly firmer support that many back sleepers appreciate. The memory foam gradually conforms to your lower back's curve, filling gaps for comprehensive support. However, the slower response time might frustrate combination sleepers who frequently shift positions.
Side sleepers typically prefer Nectar's superior pressure relief. The memory foam generously cushions shoulders and hips, preventing uncomfortable pressure buildup. Lightweight to average-weight side sleepers find the contouring particularly beneficial for maintaining proper alignment.
Brooklyn Bedding's medium model works for many side sleepers, though those under 130 pounds might prefer the soft option for enhanced cushioning. The hybrid construction provides decent pressure relief, but doesn't match Nectar's deep contouring capabilities.
Stomach sleepers need firmer support to prevent excessive hip sinkage, making Brooklyn Bedding's firm option ideal. The responsive surface maintains proper alignment while preventing the "stuck" feeling some experience with memory foam.
Nectar's medium-firm rating might work for lightweight stomach sleepers, but those over 130 pounds often find insufficient support. The memory foam's slow response can make breathing difficult for strict stomach sleepers who need to turn their heads frequently.
Motion isolation matters for couples, and here's where construction differences become apparent. Nectar's dense memory foam excels at absorbing movement, earning top marks for motion isolation. Your partner's tossing and turning virtually disappears into the foam layers.
Brooklyn Bedding's individually wrapped coils perform surprisingly well for a hybrid, isolating motion better than traditional innerspring designs. While not quite matching Nectar's performance, most couples find the motion transfer perfectly acceptable.
Edge support tells a different story. Brooklyn Bedding's coil reinforcement creates stable edges that support sitting or sleeping near the perimeter. Nectar's all-foam construction compresses more at the edges, though reinforced perimeter foam prevents excessive collapse.
Hot sleepers consistently prefer Brooklyn Bedding's superior temperature regulation. The coil system creates natural airflow channels that dissipate body heat effectively. Combined with breathable foam layers, the hybrid design maintains a temperature-neutral sleeping surface.
Nectar addresses common memory foam heat retention through gel infusion and a moisture-wicking cover. While these features help, the dense foam construction inherently traps more heat than hybrid alternatives. Most average sleepers find Nectar's temperature acceptable, but true hot sleepers might struggle.
Both brands position themselves as value options, but pricing structures differ:
| Size | Brooklyn Bedding | Nectar |
| Twin | $665 | $699 |
| Twin XL | $832 | $899 |
| Full | $999 | $949 |
| Queen | $999 | $1,099 |
| King | $1,599 | $1,399 |
| California King | $1,599 | $1,399 |
Brooklyn Bedding typically costs less, especially in smaller sizes. However, frequent promotions from both brands can significantly impact final pricing. Nectar often bundles free accessories like pillows and sheets, potentially offsetting the higher base price.
Consider long-term value beyond initial cost. Brooklyn Bedding's customizable firmness options reduce the risk of choosing wrong, while Nectar's lifetime warranty provides exceptional peace of mind.
Nectar's 365-night trial period stands out as one of the industry's longest, giving you a full year to evaluate your purchase. This extended timeframe particularly benefits those transitioning from different mattress types.
Brooklyn Bedding offers a respectable 120-night trial, requiring a 30-day break-in period before initiating returns. While shorter than Nectar's offering, four months provides ample time for most sleepers to decide.
The warranty comparison heavily favors Nectar's lifetime coverage against manufacturing defects. This forever warranty demonstrates exceptional confidence in product durability.
Brooklyn Bedding's 10-year warranty matches industry standards but feels limited compared to Nectar's offering. However, the hybrid construction typically proves more durable than all-foam designs, potentially offsetting warranty length differences.
Both companies facilitate hassle-free returns within trial periods, but details vary. Nectar provides free returns with full refunds, only excluding shipping fees for Alaska and Hawaii residents.
Brooklyn Bedding charges a $99 return fee, which some find reasonable given the company's lower initial pricing. Both brands donate returned mattresses to charity when possible, supporting environmental sustainability.
Focusing solely on price: While budget matters, the cheapest option isn't always best value. Consider trial periods, warranties, and expected lifespan alongside initial cost.
Ignoring sleep position needs: Stomach sleepers choosing Nectar's memory foam often experience inadequate support, while side sleepers picking Brooklyn Bedding's firm option miss crucial pressure relief.
Overlooking temperature preferences: Hot sleepers consistently report better experiences with Brooklyn Bedding's hybrid design. Don't underestimate how sleep temperature affects overall satisfaction.
Rushing the decision: Take advantage of generous trial periods. Your body needs time to adjust to new sleep surfaces, especially when switching between foam types.
Test firmness preferences first: Visit local mattress stores to identify your ideal firmness level. While you can't try these specific models, understanding your preferences helps choose between Brooklyn Bedding's options or determine if Nectar's single firmness works.
Consider your sleeping style: Combination sleepers who change positions frequently typically prefer Brooklyn Bedding's responsive surface. Those who maintain one position benefit from Nectar's superior contouring.
Factor in partner preferences: Couples with different firmness needs might appreciate Brooklyn Bedding's split king option, allowing customized comfort on each side.
Plan for the future: Think beyond current needs. Brooklyn Bedding's firmness options accommodate changing preferences, while Nectar's lifetime warranty provides long-term security.
While Nectar offers a lifetime warranty, Brooklyn Bedding's hybrid construction typically proves more durable. Coils resist permanent body impressions better than foam, potentially lasting 8-10 years versus 6-8 years for all-foam designs.
Yes, both mattresses work perfectly with adjustable bases. Brooklyn Bedding's flexible coil system and Nectar's all-foam construction bend without damage, enhancing comfort for reading or watching TV in bed.
Brooklyn Bedding generally serves heavier individuals better, especially in medium or firm options. The coil support system prevents excessive sinkage while maintaining proper alignment for those over 230 pounds.
Both mattresses may exhibit mild off-gassing odors initially. Brooklyn Bedding's CertiPUR-US certified foams typically air out within 24-48 hours. Nectar might take slightly longer due to denser foam construction, but odors remain harmless and dissipate quickly.
Brooklyn Bedding manufactures domestically and typically ships within 2-5 business days. Nectar's shipping times vary more, sometimes taking 1-2 weeks depending on location and demand.
Choose Brooklyn Bedding if you value responsive support, temperature regulation, and firmness customization. The hybrid design particularly suits combination sleepers, hot sleepers, and those sharing their bed. The bouncy surface facilitates easy movement and intimate activities.
Select Nectar for superior pressure relief, motion isolation, and that classic memory foam feel. Side sleepers and those prioritizing warranty length find exceptional value here. The generous trial period provides confidence for memory foam newcomers.
Both mattresses deliver quality sleep at reasonable prices. Your personal preferences, sleeping style, and partner considerations should guide the final decision. Take advantage of generous trial periods to ensure your choice delivers the restorative sleep you deserve.
Ready to transform your sleep? Explore more bedroom furniture options and bedding essentials to complete your perfect sleep sanctuary. Don't forget to check our guide on when to buy a mattress for maximum savings. For additional mattress insights, visit trusted resources like Consumer Reports' buying guide.