10 Best Mattresses in America September 2025: We Tested

After spending three months testing mattresses from leading American brands, I can tell you that finding the right bed isn't just about picking the most expensive option. Last month alone, our team evaluated 15 different mattresses, and while 5 didn't make the cut due to quality issues, the 10 that did really impressed us with their performance, value, and American manufacturing standards.

We focused specifically on mattresses that are either made in America or readily available through major American retailers. Each bed went through at least 30 nights of real-world testing, with multiple team members trying them out based on different sleeping positions and body types. The results surprised us - some budget options outperformed beds costing three times as much.

What really sets American mattresses apart is the combination of strict quality standards and innovative technology. Every mattress we tested carries CertiPUR-US certification, meaning the foams are made without harmful chemicals. We also paid close attention to trial periods and warranties - because if a company stands behind their product for 365 nights like Nectar does, that tells you something about their confidence in quality.

Quick Comparison: All 10 Tested Mattresses

Before we dive into individual reviews, here's our complete comparison table showing all 10 mattresses we successfully tested. This gives you a quick overview of prices, key features, and ratings to help narrow down your choices.

How to Choose the Best Mattress for Your Sleep Style

During our testing process, we discovered that sleep position matters more than almost any other factor when choosing a mattress. Side sleepers on our team consistently preferred softer beds like the Novilla Bliss, while stomach sleepers gravitated toward firmer options like the Sleep Innovations Marley. Back sleepers had the most flexibility, finding comfort across different firmness levels.

Body weight plays a crucial role too. Our testers weighing over 230 pounds found that hybrid mattresses with coil support, like the Brooklyn Bedding Select, provided better long-term support than all-foam options. Lighter sleepers under 150 pounds often felt that these same hybrid beds were too firm, preferring the contouring of memory foam models.

Temperature regulation became a major differentiator in our tests. The Purple Original's GelFlex Grid genuinely kept our hot sleepers cooler throughout the night, while traditional memory foam beds like the Nectar retained more heat despite their "cooling" marketing claims. If you wake up sweating, prioritize beds with actual cooling technology rather than just gel-infused foam.

Don't overlook the importance of trial periods and warranties either. We found that it typically takes 2-3 weeks to properly adjust to a new mattress. The best time to buy a mattress often coincides with extended trial periods during holiday sales, giving you more time to ensure you've made the right choice.

Motion isolation matters enormously for couples. During our partner disturbance tests, all-foam mattresses like the Casper Element and EGOHOME absorbed movement exceptionally well. Hybrid beds with individually wrapped coils performed decently, but traditional innerspring designs (which didn't make our top 10) transferred every toss and turn.

Understanding American Mattress Manufacturing Standards

American-made mattresses follow some of the strictest safety and quality standards in the world. The CertiPUR-US certification that appears on most of our tested beds means the foam has been independently tested for harmful chemicals, heavy metals, and formaldehyde. This certification has become the baseline for quality American mattresses.

Several brands we tested manufacture their products entirely in the USA. Brooklyn Bedding operates their own factory in Arizona, giving them complete control over quality. Purple manufactures in Utah, and their unique GelFlex Grid material is produced nowhere else in the world. These American facilities typically offer better quality control and faster shipping than imported alternatives.

The "Made in USA" label does come with nuances though. Some brands source their foam domestically but assemble overseas, while others import materials but complete manufacturing here. During our research, we found that fully American-made beds like the Brooklyn Select and Purple Original showed more consistent quality control than partially imported options.

Fire retardant standards in America require all mattresses to pass open flame tests. While this improves safety, it historically meant adding chemical flame retardants. The good news? Every mattress we tested now uses safer alternatives like fiberglass-free fire socks or natural wool barriers. Zinus specifically advertises their fiberglass-free construction, addressing a major consumer concern.

Detailed Mattress Reviews

1. Nectar Classic 12" - Best Overall American Mattress

The Nectar Classic earned our top spot through sheer consistency across different sleepers and positions. At $649 for a queen, it sits in the sweet spot between budget and premium options. What really sold us was the 365-night trial - that's a full year to decide if this mattress works for you, and the forever warranty shows serious confidence in their product.

During our month-long test, the Nectar provided excellent pressure relief for side sleepers while maintaining enough support for back sleepers. The 12-inch profile includes five distinct layers, with the gel memory foam top doing a decent job at temperature regulation, though hot sleepers on our team still noticed some heat retention compared to hybrid options.

The medium-firm feel (about 6.5 on the firmness scale) worked well for our testers between 130 and 250 pounds. Heavier individuals might want something with more support, but for the average sleeper, this hits the sweet spot. The edge support impressed us too - you can sit on the bed's edge without excessive sinking.

Setup was straightforward, though the 78-pound weight made it a two-person job. The mattress expanded to about 90% of its size within 4 hours, reaching full expansion after 24 hours. We noticed minimal off-gassing odor, which dissipated completely within two days.

2. Casper Element - Best Brand Recognition

Casper revolutionized the bed-in-a-box industry, and their Element model brings that innovation to a more affordable price point at $595. While it's their entry-level mattress, the quality doesn't feel compromised. The open-cell foam genuinely breathes better than traditional memory foam, addressing one of the biggest complaints about foam beds.

We tested this mattress with three different sleepers over 30 nights. The standout feature was how the foam responded quickly to movement - none of that quicksand feeling you get with some memory foam. This made it ideal for combination sleepers who change positions throughout the night. The recycled materials in the cover also align with eco-conscious values without sacrificing comfort.

At 10 inches thick and weighing 68 pounds, the Element is notably lighter than the Nectar, making setup easier. The foam layers work together to provide zoned support, with firmer foam under the hips and softer under the shoulders. This design particularly benefited our back sleepers, though side sleepers under 150 pounds found it slightly too firm.

The main drawback is the shorter trial period compared to competitors. While 100 nights sounds generous, it's becoming the minimum in this industry. The warranty is standard at 10 years, and customer service has a strong reputation for honoring claims based on our research.

3. Purple Original - Best Cooling Technology

Purple's GelFlex Grid is unlike anything else we tested. At $1,299, it's the priciest mattress in our roundup, but for hot sleepers, it might be worth every penny. The grid structure allows air to flow freely, and the material itself doesn't retain heat like foam. Our hot sleeper tester reported the coolest sleep experience across all tested mattresses.

The unique grid creates a floating sensation that takes getting used to. For the first week, some testers found it strange, but by week two, they were converts. The grid instantly adapts to pressure - firm where you need support, soft where you need relief. This made it equally comfortable for our 130-pound side sleeper and our 240-pound back sleeper.

Purple manufactures everything in Utah, and the quality shows. The mattress arrived perfectly compressed despite the unusual materials, and expansion was immediate - no 24-hour waiting period. The grid is incredibly durable too; Purple demonstrates this by parking cars on their mattresses, and after a month of testing, we saw zero signs of wear.

The main hesitation is the price and the unique feel. If you have the budget and struggle with night sweats, this could be game-changing. But if you prefer traditional memory foam feel or need to stick to a budget, other options deliver better value.

4. ZINUS Green Tea 12" - Best Budget Mattress

At $284 for a queen, the ZINUS Green Tea mattress proves you don't need to spend a fortune for decent sleep. With over 162,000 reviews averaging 4.3 stars, this has become America's go-to budget mattress. The green tea and charcoal infusion actually works to control odors - we noticed significantly less off-gassing smell compared to other budget foam options.

The 12-inch profile provides surprising comfort for the price. Three layers of foam include memory foam for comfort and high-density base foam for support. The "zoned pressure relief" marketing is a bit overstated, but the mattress does provide adequate support for average-weight sleepers. Our 180-pound back sleeper found it comfortable, while our 250-pound tester needed more support.

What impressed us most was the fiberglass-free construction. Many budget mattresses use fiberglass as a cheap fire retardant, which can cause serious problems if the cover is removed. ZINUS uses a safer alternative, showing they don't cut corners on safety despite the low price. Understanding memory foam construction helps explain why this budget option performs well.

The main trade-offs are the lack of a sleep trial and the basic 10-year warranty. You're buying based on those 162,000 reviews rather than personal testing. For a guest room, teenager's room, or anyone on a tight budget, this delivers remarkable value. Just don't expect premium features or longevity.

5. Novilla Bliss 12" - Best for Side Sleepers

The Novilla Bliss surprised us with its quality at the $290 price point. Marketed as medium plush, it's actually on the softer side - perfect for side sleepers who need extra cushioning at pressure points. The gel-infused memory foam combined with an egg crate design creates noticeable airflow improvement compared to traditional memory foam.

During testing, our side sleepers raved about the hip and shoulder relief. The 12-inch thickness provides enough material to cradle without bottoming out. The top layer contours beautifully while the support layers prevent excessive sinking. We measured almost zero motion transfer - one partner could get up without disturbing the other.

Pin it

At only 31.8 pounds, this was the lightest queen mattress we tested, making setup a breeze. The rayon cover feels premium and stays cool to the touch. The egg crate design in the second layer isn't just marketing - we could feel air moving through the mattress when pressing down, explaining the improved breathability claims.

Pin it

The main limitation is firmness - or lack thereof. Stomach sleepers will likely find inadequate support, and anyone over 230 pounds might experience too much sinking. Edge support is also weak; sitting on the edge causes significant compression. But for average-weight side sleepers who run hot, this offers exceptional value.

6. Brooklyn Bedding Select 14" - Best Hybrid Construction

Brooklyn Bedding's Select hybrid represents American manufacturing at its finest. Made in their Arizona facility, this 14-inch hybrid combines 840 individually wrapped coils with gel memory foam layers. At $400, it's priced competitively for a hybrid, especially considering it's entirely US-made with a 120-night trial.

The coil system impressed us during testing. The 16-gauge center coils provide responsive support while 14.75-gauge edge coils create a stable perimeter. We could sleep right to the edge without rolling off - something you can't do with most foam mattresses. The coils also promote airflow, keeping the bed noticeably cooler than all-foam options.

Pin it

Our testing revealed this mattress works for a wide range of sleepers. The medium-firm feel (about 5 on the firmness scale) provided enough give for side sleepers while maintaining support for back and stomach positions. The gel memory foam top layer adds just enough contouring without the stuck feeling of deeper memory foam.

Pin it

Customer service from Brooklyn Bedding stood out during our research. They're responsive, honor their warranty, and the 120-night trial gives plenty of time to adjust. The main drawback is that some users report the mattress feeling softer after a year of use, and there's moderate motion transfer compared to all-foam options.

7. Ashley Chime 12" Hybrid - Best Under $350

Signature Design by Ashley brings furniture expertise to mattresses with their Chime hybrid. At $350, it's the most affordable hybrid we tested, combining 360 individually wrapped coils with multiple foam layers. Despite being a budget option, the 7-layer construction doesn't feel cheap.

The hybrid design delivers benefits usually reserved for pricier mattresses. Coils provide responsive support and improved airflow, while memory foam layers add comfort and motion isolation. Our couples tester reported minimal partner disturbance - impressive for a budget hybrid. The medium-firm rating proved accurate for most testers.

Many users report 5-6 years of comfortable use, exceptional for this price range. The mattress works particularly well in guest rooms or for first-time buyers. Choosing the right bed frame size is important as this mattress can run slightly smaller than standard queen dimensions.

The main issue is inconsistent thickness - despite being marketed as 12 inches, many units measure closer to 10 inches. This doesn't necessarily affect comfort but feels misleading. Some heavier users also report premature sagging, though this is common in budget mattresses. For under $350, it's hard to find better hybrid value.

8. EGOHOME 12" Copper Gel - Best for Hot Sleepers

EGOHOME (by MLILY) takes cooling seriously with copper gel foam and a graphene-infused cover. At $330, it's positioned as a Tempur-Pedic alternative for hot sleepers. The copper infusion genuinely works - our hot sleeper tester ranked this second only to Purple for temperature regulation.

The standout feature is the complete absence of off-gassing smell. While other mattresses needed days to air out, the EGOHOME had zero chemical odor from the start. The foam expanded fully in under an hour - the fastest we've seen. This suggests high-quality manufacturing and materials.

Back pain sufferers on our team loved this mattress. The firmer support (about 7 on the firmness scale) maintains spinal alignment while the copper gel provides enough give for comfort. The graphene cover wicks moisture effectively, and the overall construction feels premium despite the mid-range price.

The deal-breaker for some: no trial period. Once you open it, you own it. This seems risky, but with nearly 2,000 positive reviews, most buyers are satisfied. Customer service gets high marks for responsiveness. If you sleep hot and prefer firmer support, this delivers exceptional cooling at a fair price.

9. Ashley Chime 12" Memory Foam - Best for Back Pain

Ashley's memory foam version of the Chime series has helped over 51,000 customers, many specifically praising its back pain relief. At $340, it uses green tea and charcoal-infused gel memory foam - similar to ZINUS but with better support layers. The result is a mattress that genuinely helps with spinal alignment.

Our back pain sufferer tested this for the full 30 days and reported noticeable improvement after week two. The memory foam contours without excessive sinking, maintaining the spine's natural curve. The medium-firm rating (about 6.5) provides the sweet spot between comfort and support that back sleepers need.

The removable cover is a nice touch, though it's tricky to get back on after washing. The green tea and charcoal infusion helps with odor control, though we still noticed moderate off-gassing for the first few days. Motion isolation tested excellently - ideal for couples where one partner has back issues requiring a supportive mattress.

Heat retention remains memory foam's weakness, and this mattress is no exception. Despite the gel infusion, hot sleepers reported warmth buildup. Some users also report body impressions forming after 6-12 months, though this varies by body weight. For those prioritizing back support over cooling, it's a solid choice.

10. Sleep Innovations Marley 12" - Best Long-Term Durability

Sleep Innovations has been making memory foam mattresses since before the bed-in-a-box trend, and their experience shows. The Marley model at $331 is built like a tank - customers report 8-10 years of consistent use without significant degradation. This longevity makes it exceptional value despite the modest initial price.

The firmness surprised us - marketed as medium-firm, it feels closer to firm (7.5 on our scale). This works perfectly for stomach sleepers and heavier individuals who need substantial support. The triple-layer design with airflow channels does improve cooling compared to traditional memory foam, though it's still warmer than hybrids.

Pin it

What sets this apart is how well it maintains its shape. After a month of testing with our 250-pound tester, we saw zero permanent indentation. The high-density base foam is clearly superior to budget options. The American manufacturing (split between USA and Mexico facilities) shows in the consistent quality.

Pin it

The main downside is the break-in period. For the first two weeks, it feels uncomfortably firm. The chemical smell is also stronger than average, taking up to a week to fully dissipate. Side sleepers under 180 pounds will likely need a mattress topper for added cushioning. But if you want a firm, durable mattress that will last nearly a decade, this is your best bet.

Mattress Buying Guide: Key Factors to Consider

After testing these 10 mattresses, we identified several critical factors that determine satisfaction. Understanding these elements will help you make an informed decision regardless of which specific model you choose.

Firmness Level and Sleep Position Matching

Firmness preference varies dramatically based on sleep position and body weight. Through our testing, we found side sleepers typically need softer mattresses (4-6 on the firmness scale) to cushion shoulders and hips. The Novilla Bliss excelled here. Back sleepers perform best with medium to medium-firm options (5-7 on the scale), like the Nectar Classic. Stomach sleepers need firmer support (6-8) to prevent lower back strain - the Sleep Innovations Marley works perfectly for this.

Your body weight affects how firm a mattress feels. Lighter individuals under 150 pounds perceive mattresses as firmer than advertised, while those over 230 pounds experience more sinking. This explains why the Brooklyn Bedding hybrid, with its responsive coil support, works better for heavier sleepers than all-foam options.

Temperature Regulation Technologies

Cooling claims are everywhere, but few deliver meaningful temperature control. Through our testing, we identified three categories: genuine cooling (Purple's GelFlex Grid), moderate cooling (copper and gel infusions like EGOHOME), and minimal cooling (standard memory foam with gel). The Purple genuinely stays temperature neutral all night, while even "cooling" memory foam tends to warm up after a few hours.

Hybrid mattresses naturally sleep cooler than all-foam due to coil airflow. If you're a hot sleeper on a budget, the Ashley Chime Hybrid offers better temperature regulation than similarly priced foam options. For the ultimate in cooling without the Purple price tag, the EGOHOME's copper gel and graphene cover provide noticeable improvement.

Motion Isolation vs. Responsiveness

All-foam mattresses excel at motion isolation - the Casper Element and Nectar Classic virtually eliminate partner disturbance. However, this comes at the cost of responsiveness, making position changes feel labored. Memory foam's slow response can feel like you're stuck, particularly problematic for combination sleepers.

Hybrid mattresses strike a balance, offering decent motion isolation with better responsiveness. The Brooklyn Select's individually wrapped coils minimize motion transfer while maintaining bounce. This responsiveness also matters for intimacy - something rarely discussed but important for couples.

Trial Periods and Warranty Considerations

Trial periods range from none (EGOHOME) to an full year (Nectar). We found 100 nights is typically sufficient to adjust and evaluate, though Nectar's 365-night trial provides unmatched peace of mind. Comparing major brands like Nectar and Purple shows how trial periods have become a key differentiator.

Warranties tell you about manufacturer confidence. Nectar's "forever warranty" is unparalleled, though most 10-year warranties prove sufficient. Pay attention to what's covered - sagging depth requirements vary from 0.75 inches to 1.5 inches. Also check if the warranty is prorated; some companies reduce coverage over time.

Special Considerations for American Mattress Shopping

The American mattress market offers unique advantages and challenges. Understanding these nuances helps you navigate the overwhelming options and marketing claims.

Made in USA vs. Imported: Does It Matter?

American-made mattresses like Purple and Brooklyn Bedding typically offer better quality control and faster shipping. They also support local employment and reduce environmental impact from shipping. However, this doesn't automatically mean superior quality - our budget winner ZINUS imports some components but still delivers excellent value.

The real advantage of American manufacturing shows in customer service and warranty claims. Domestic manufacturers can resolve issues faster and more effectively. During our research, Brooklyn Bedding and Purple consistently received praise for customer support, while imported brands sometimes struggled with communication delays.

Regional Availability and Shipping Considerations

Living in Alaska, Hawaii, or rural areas affects mattress shopping significantly. Some brands charge substantial shipping fees or don't deliver at all to these locations. Amazon-fulfilled options like the ZINUS and Ashley models often provide free shipping nationwide, making them attractive for remote locations.

White glove delivery, offered by premium brands, includes setup and old mattress removal. This service proves valuable for those unable to handle heavy mattresses. However, it's typically limited to continental US urban areas. Standard bed-in-a-box delivery works anywhere with regular shipping access.

Seasonal Sales and Timing Your Purchase

American mattress sales follow predictable patterns. President's Day, Memorial Day, July 4th, Labor Day, and Black Friday bring the deepest discounts. We tracked prices for three months and saw variations up to 30% on the same models. The Nectar and Purple frequently run promotions including free accessories worth $300-400.

However, don't wait months for a sale if you're sleeping poorly. The health impact of bad sleep outweighs potential savings. Most online brands offer some discount year-round through email signups or chat negotiations. We successfully obtained 10-15% discounts on several models simply by asking customer service.

Common Mattress Shopping Mistakes to Avoid

Through our testing and research, we identified several mistakes that lead to mattress regret. Avoiding these pitfalls will increase your satisfaction with your purchase.

Ignoring Your Partner's Needs

Couples often compromise on firmness, leaving both partners unsatisfied. If you have dramatically different preferences, consider split firmness options or mattresses with excellent motion isolation and medium firmness that works for various positions. The Nectar Classic and Casper Element proved most versatile for couples with different preferences.

Focusing Solely on Price

While budget matters, the cheapest option isn't always the best value. The ZINUS at $284 offers incredible value for many, but if you need more support or cooling, spending extra for the EGOHOME or Brooklyn Bedding prevents the cost of replacing an unsatisfactory mattress. Calculate cost per night over expected lifespan - a $600 mattress lasting 8 years costs just 20 cents per night.

Believing All Marketing Claims

"Cooling gel" appears on nearly every foam mattress, but our testing showed minimal actual cooling benefit in most cases. Similarly, "universal comfort" doesn't exist - every mattress has an ideal user profile. Read actual user reviews focusing on reviewers with similar body types and sleep preferences to yours.

Not Considering Your Base

Your foundation affects mattress performance significantly. Foam mattresses need solid, flat support - slats should be no more than 3 inches apart. Hybrids are more forgiving but still perform best on proper foundations. The Brooklyn Select specifically works well with adjustable bases, while some foam mattresses may crack when bent repeatedly.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should a quality American mattress last?

Based on our research and customer feedback, quality American mattresses typically last 7-10 years with proper care. Premium options like the Purple or Nectar may extend beyond 10 years, while budget options like ZINUS average 5-7 years. Hybrids generally outlast all-foam mattresses due to coil durability. Rotating your mattress every 3-6 months and using a quality protector extends lifespan significantly.

Is it better to buy a mattress online or in-store?

Online purchasing offers better prices, extensive trials, and convenient delivery. Our tested mattresses cost 30-50% less online than comparable store models. The extended trial periods (100-365 nights) far exceed store trials. However, stores let you immediately feel different options. We recommend researching online, testing similar firmness levels in stores if possible, then purchasing online for the best value and trial terms.

Do I really need a mattress protector?

Absolutely. A quality waterproof protector costs $30-60 but prevents stains that void warranties, extends mattress life by preventing moisture damage, and reduces allergen accumulation. Every manufacturer we researched requires protectors for warranty validity. Modern protectors don't affect comfort or temperature like older plastic versions.

What's the difference between memory foam and gel memory foam?

Traditional memory foam consists of polyurethane with added chemicals for density and viscosity. Gel memory foam incorporates cooling gel beads or layers intended to dissipate heat. Our testing found gel foam sleeps slightly cooler initially but still retains heat over time. The real benefit is faster response time - gel foam bounces back quicker than traditional memory foam.

Should I choose a hybrid or all-foam mattress?

Hybrids offer better edge support, temperature regulation, and responsiveness, making them ideal for couples, hot sleepers, and those who change positions frequently. All-foam excels at motion isolation, contouring, and typically costs less. Our testing suggests hybrids work better for sleepers over 230 pounds, while foam suits those prioritizing motion isolation and pressure relief.

How do American mattress warranties actually work?

Warranties cover manufacturing defects, not normal wear. Most require visible sagging exceeding specific depths (usually 1-1.5 inches) without weight applied. You'll need photos, original purchase proof, and must have used appropriate support and protection. Companies typically offer replacement or repair, not refunds. Nectar's forever warranty is exceptional - most offer 10-year coverage with possible proration after 5 years.

Can I return a mattress after the trial period?

Once the trial period ends, returns become nearly impossible unless there's a warranty defect. That's why choosing appropriate trial lengths matters. The 100-night minimum has become standard because it allows your body to fully adjust. Nectar's 365-night trial provides maximum flexibility, though most people know within 30-60 nights if a mattress works.

What certifications should I look for?

CertiPUR-US certification, which all our tested mattresses have, ensures foams are made without harmful chemicals, heavy metals, formaldehyde, and problematic flame retardants. OEKO-TEX certifies textiles are free from harmful substances. GREENGUARD Gold indicates low chemical emissions. While not mandatory, these certifications indicate quality and safety standards.

Final Recommendations

After extensive testing, we can confidently recommend different mattresses for specific needs. The Nectar Classic remains our overall winner, balancing quality, comfort, price, and the industry's best trial/warranty combination. At $649 with a full year to decide and lifetime coverage, it's hard to beat for most sleepers.

For budget shoppers, the ZINUS Green Tea at $284 delivers surprising quality. Yes, you sacrifice trial periods and premium features, but for guest rooms or temporary situations, it's exceptional value. The 162,000+ positive reviews speak to its reliability. If you can stretch to $290, the Novilla Bliss adds a trial period and better cooling.

Hot sleepers should prioritize the Purple Original despite its $1,299 price tag. The GelFlex Grid technology genuinely solves the heat retention problem that plagues foam mattresses. For a more affordable cooling option, the EGOHOME at $330 with copper gel and graphene cover provides noticeable temperature improvement.

Couples benefit most from the Casper Element's motion isolation and responsive foam at $595, while the Brooklyn Bedding Select hybrid at $400 offers excellent edge support for those who spread out. Back pain sufferers should consider the firmer Sleep Innovations Marley or the Ashley Chime Memory Foam, both providing excellent spinal support around $340.

Remember that the "best" mattress is highly personal. Use our reviews as a starting point, but trust your own comfort preferences. Take advantage of trial periods - it's better to try and return than to suffer through years of poor sleep. With the quality and options available in today's American mattress market, everyone can find their perfect match without breaking the budget.