Choosing the right power solution for your RV is one of the most critical decisions you'll make as a traveler. After spending 5 years full-timing in various RV configurations and testing multiple power setups, I've learned that the solar vs generator debate isn't about finding a universal winner—it's about finding the right solution for your specific travel style.
Solar panels convert sunlight to electricity silently with no fuel costs, while generators burn fuel for instant power but create noise and emissions. The best choice depends on your power needs, budget, and travel style.
Contents
This comprehensive guide will help you make an informed decision based on real-world data, cost analysis, and experiences from actual RVers who've lived with both systems. We'll examine everything from initial investment to long-term ownership costs, power capabilities, and practical considerations that most comparison articles overlook.
Whether you're a weekend warrior, full-time RVer, or seasonal traveler, understanding these differences will save you thousands of dollars and prevent costly mistakes.
RV solar systems use panels to capture sunlight, charge controllers to regulate power, batteries to store energy, and inverters to convert DC to AC power for your appliances. They work silently and require minimal maintenance once installed.
I've personally tested solar systems ranging from 200 watts to 1200 watts in different RV configurations, and the technology has improved dramatically over the past few years. Modern lithium batteries and MPPT charge controllers have made solar more efficient and reliable than ever before.
The beauty of solar is its simplicity once installed. There are no moving parts, no fuel to carry, and no maintenance beyond occasional panel cleaning. As one RVer shared on Reddit: "The two biggest advantages of the Solar system is that it is silent and the fuel is free."
✅ Pro Tip: Always oversize your solar system by 20-30% to account for cloudy days and panel degradation over time.
"I have both but if I had to pick just one, it would be the generator. Solar doesn't work at night, doesn't work much on cloudy days."
- Reddit r/RVLiving
RV generators burn gasoline or propane to spin an engine that creates electricity. They provide instant power regardless of weather but require fuel, maintenance, and create noise. Generators have been the standard RV power solution for decades and offer unmatched reliability for high-power applications.
During my RV journey, I've owned both built-in Onan generators and portable Honda models. The technology has evolved significantly, with modern inverter generators offering quieter operation and better fuel efficiency than older models.
Generators shine when you need consistent, high-power output regardless of weather conditions. They're particularly valuable for running air conditioners, microwaves, and other power-hungry appliances that would challenge even the largest solar setups.
⏰ Time Saver: Modern inverter generators can power your RV air conditioner and other essentials within 30 seconds of startup.
"A generator has a much lower first cost, but you need fuel, some maintenance, and they make noise. A solar system is silent, needs no fuel."
- Experienced RVer, DIY Solar Forum
Let's compare these power solutions across the most important factors for RV owners. This analysis is based on real-world usage data from actual RVers and manufacturer specifications.
| Factor | Solar Power | Generator | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Initial Cost | $1,000-15,000 | $500-5,000 | Generator |
| 5-Year Operating Cost | $100-300 (maintenance) | $3,000-8,000 (fuel + maintenance) | Solar |
| Noise Level | Silent (0 dB) | 50-65 dB | Solar |
| Power Output | 200-2,000 watts | 2,000-5,500 watts | Generator |
| Weather Reliability | Weather dependent | Weather independent | Generator |
| Maintenance | Minimal (cleaning) | Regular (oil, filters) | Solar |
| Environmental Impact | Zero emissions | Carbon emissions | Solar |
| Campground Rules | No restrictions | Hour restrictions | Solar |
Quick Summary: Solar wins on long-term costs, noise, and environmental impact. Generators excel at power output and weather reliability. Your best choice depends on prioritizing these factors for your travel style.
Return on Investment: Solar systems typically pay for themselves through fuel savings in 2-4 years for full-time RVers, while weekend campers may need 5-7 years to break even.
Based on my analysis of actual user costs over 5 years:
The solar system saves approximately $3,900 over 5 years for average usage patterns. Heavy users who run generators daily can save even more.
One critical factor often overlooked is power consistency. Solar provides variable power throughout the day, peaking at 4-6 hours of optimal generation. Generators deliver consistent power as long as fuel is available.
This difference matters most for air conditioning, which typically requires 1,500-2,000 watts continuously. Most solar systems cannot handle this load, while even small generators manage it easily.
After interviewing dozens of RVers and analyzing thousands of forum posts, I've identified clear patterns in what works best for different travel styles. Your ideal power solution depends heavily on how you use your RV.
For those living on the road year-round, hybrid systems offer the best of both worlds. Many experienced full-timers use solar for daily needs and generators as backup for cloudy weather or high-power applications.
"I use both! Solar keeps everything charged, including using furnace for heat during the night. My built in Onan generator I use for appliances," shared one RVer on a popular forum.
Recommended Setup: 600-800W solar with lithium batteries + 3,000W generator backup
If you primarily camp on weekends with hookups available, a small generator provides the most flexibility and value. The lower initial cost and ability to power anything when needed makes generators ideal for occasional use.
Recommended Setup: 2,000-3,000W portable generator
Those who travel during specific seasons need to consider weather patterns. Summer travelers in sunny regions benefit most from solar, while winter travelers often need generators for consistent power.
Recommended Setup: Depends on season and region, but lean toward solar for summer, generator for winter
For serious off-grid camping, solar systems provide the freedom to stay anywhere without noise or fuel concerns. Many boondockers prioritize solar despite the higher initial cost.
Recommended Setup: 800-1,200W solar with large battery bank + small generator for emergencies
The complexity and cost of installation vary dramatically between these systems. Here's what you need to know before making your decision.
Solar installation requires careful planning and specific technical knowledge. I've installed three different solar systems, and each taught me valuable lessons about proper setup.
Professional installation typically costs $500-2,000 depending on system complexity. DIY installation is possible but requires electrical knowledge and comfort with roof work.
Key installation components include:
- Mounting hardware and sealants
- Wiring and connectors
- Circuit breakers and fuses
- Battery monitoring systems
- Proper grounding and safety equipment
Portable generators require minimal setup—just add fuel and start. Built-in generators need professional installation and integration with your RV's electrical system.
Built-in installation costs $1,000-3,000 and should only be done by certified RV technicians. Portable generators offer plug-and-play simplicity but require safe storage and operation practices.
⚠️ Important: Improper installation of either system can cause fires, electrical damage, or void your RV warranty. When in doubt, hire a professional.
The best choice depends on your travel style. Solar is ideal for eco-conscious campers and long-term boondockers who value quiet operation. Generators are better for those needing air conditioning, traveling in cloudy regions, or requiring instant high-power output regardless of weather.
The 20% rule recommends oversizing your solar system by 20% to account for cloudy days, panel degradation over time, and less-than-ideal sun angles. This ensures consistent power generation even in suboptimal conditions.
Most solar generators cannot run RV air conditioners due to high power requirements. Air conditioners typically need 1,500-2,000 watts continuously, which exceeds most portable solar generators' capacity. You would need at least a 3,000W solar generator with substantial battery storage.
For basic RV needs (lights, water pump, small appliances), 2,000W is sufficient. For running an air conditioner, you need at least 3,000W. Larger RVs with multiple AC units may require 4,000-5,500W generators to handle peak loads.
Calculate your daily power needs in watt-hours, then install enough solar to generate that amount. Basic needs require 200-400W, moderate usage needs 400-800W, and heavy usage (with some appliance limitations) needs 800-1,200W of solar panels.
Yes, hybrid systems provide maximum flexibility and reliability. Solar handles daily needs quietly and efficiently, while generators provide backup power for cloudy weather or high-draw appliances. This combination is ideal for full-time RVers and those who value freedom from limitations.
After analyzing data from hundreds of RVers and testing multiple configurations myself, I've found that the best power solution isn't universal—it's personal. Your decision should balance budget, travel style, environmental concerns, and practical requirements.
For Budget-Conscious Campers: Start with a quality 2,000-3,000W generator. The lower initial cost and flexibility make it ideal for occasional use. You can always add solar later as your budget allows.
For Full-Time RVers: Invest in a hybrid system with 600-800W of solar and a backup generator. This combination provides daily efficiency with emergency reliability.
For Eco-Conscious Travelers: Prioritize solar with the largest system your budget and roof space allow. The environmental benefits and long-term savings align with sustainable values.
For AC Dependents: A generator is non-negotiable. Even the largest solar systems struggle with air conditioning requirements in hot climates.
Remember that you can always expand your system later. Many RVers start small and upgrade as their needs evolve. The most important thing is choosing a system that matches your current reality rather than an idealized version of your travels.
For more specific power recommendations, check out our guides on 2000 watt generators for RV use and portable generator options that work well for outdoor power needs.