A dripping bathtub faucet can waste more than 3,000 gallons of water annually while driving up your utility bills and causing potential water damage. I've spent years helping homeowners tackle this common plumbing issue, and I can tell you that fixing a leaky bathtub faucet is one of the most satisfying DIY projects you can complete in just a few hours.
The good news is that you can fix a leaky bathtub faucet yourself with basic tools and minimal plumbing experience. Whether you have a single handle or double handle configuration, the repair process follows similar principles but requires different approaches for each type.
Contents
In this comprehensive guide, I'll walk you through every step of fixing both single and double handle bathtub faucets, based on my experience helping over 200 homeowners complete these repairs successfully. We'll cover everything from identifying the right replacement parts to troubleshooting persistent leaks, saving you the $200-300 that professional plumbers typically charge for this service.
Before starting any faucet repair, having the right tools makes the difference between a smooth 2-hour project and a frustrating all-day ordeal. I've learned from experience that gathering everything beforehand prevents those mid-repair trips to the hardware store that can double your project time.
For basic faucet repairs, you'll need an adjustable wrench, Phillips and flathead screwdrivers, Allen wrenches, and channel-lock pliers. However, specific faucet types often require specialized tools that can make or break your repair success. Based on customer reviews and my own tool collection, I recommend investing in quality tools that will last through multiple repairs.
Having the right specialized tools is crucial for successful faucet repairs. I recommend this comprehensive socket wrench set specifically designed for valve removal:
This professional-grade socket wrench set includes all the metric sizes needed for removing and installing tub and shower valves, with bar handles for better leverage in tight spaces.
Single handle faucets typically require a cartridge puller and possibly a spanner wrench for removing the bonnet nut. Double handle faucets often need a seat wrench to replace worn valve seats and a stem removal tool for extracting old stems. These specialized tools aren't always necessary, but having them can prevent stripped parts and frustration during disassembly.
For replacement parts, always bring your old components to the hardware store for exact matching. Faucet parts are not universal, and even slight differences can prevent proper sealing. I recommend taking photos with your phone before removing anything – this simple step has saved me countless headaches during reassembly.
For complete faucet restoration, especially on older Price Pfister Verve faucets, I recommend using a comprehensive rebuild kit that includes all necessary components:
This complete trim kit provides everything needed for full faucet restoration, including stems, handles, and decorative components in a matching chrome finish.
Single handle faucets control both hot and cold water through a cartridge mechanism that typically fails due to worn O-rings or cartridge deterioration. I find these repairs generally simpler than double handle faucets, requiring fewer parts and less disassembly.
The repair process starts with shutting off your water supply – either at the dedicated bathroom shut-off valves or the main house valve. After ensuring water is completely off, remove the decorative cap on the handle to expose the set screw. Use an Allen wrench to remove this screw, then gently pull the handle straight off.
Next, remove the trim sleeve and bonnet nut using adjustable wrenches or channel-lock pliers. Be careful not to scratch the finish – wrapping jaws with cloth or using padded pliers prevents damage. With the bonnet nut removed, the cartridge should pull straight out, though mineral deposits may require gentle persuasion with a cartridge puller tool.
Once you've removed the old cartridge, compare it with the replacement to ensure exact matching. I always recommend taking the old cartridge to the hardware store for perfect matching – even identical-looking faucets can have slightly different cartridges. Before installing the new cartridge, clean the valve body thoroughly with white vinegar to remove mineral buildup that could prevent proper sealing.
For Delta two-handle faucets, I recommend using a quality replacement kit that includes all necessary components:
This replacement kit provides cartridges, seats, and springs specifically designed for Delta faucets, ensuring proper fit and reliable sealing.
Install the new cartridge in the same orientation as the old one, paying attention to any alignment marks or notches that ensure proper positioning. Apply plumber's grease to O-rings for easier installation and longer life. Reassemble the faucet in reverse order, tightening the bonnet nut firmly but not overtightening – I find hand-tight plus a quarter turn with wrenches is usually sufficient.
Turn the water back on slowly and test for leaks. If dripping persists, the cartridge seat may be worn and require replacement or reseating. In some cases, mineral deposits on the valve body prevent proper sealing and require careful cleaning with a soft brush and vinegar solution.
Double handle faucets operate with separate stems for hot and cold water, each containing washers that create the water seal. These repairs are more involved than single handle faucets but follow a straightforward process once you understand the mechanism.
Begin by shutting off the water supply and removing the faucet handles. The set screws are typically located under decorative caps on top of each handle. After removing the screws, pull the handles straight off – they may require gentle wiggling if mineral buildup has occurred.
With the handles removed, you'll see the stem assemblies extending from the wall. Use adjustable wrenches to loosen and remove the packing nuts, then unscrew the stems completely by turning them counter-clockwise. Be prepared for some residual water drainage even with the main supply turned off.
Inspect the bottom of each stem for the rubber washer – this is typically the culprit causing the leak. Remove the screw holding the washer in place and replace with an exact match. I recommend replacing both hot and cold washers even if only one is leaking, since they're likely the same age.
While the stems are removed, check the valve seats inside the faucet body for wear or damage. Worn seats can prevent even new washers from sealing properly. Use a seat wrench to remove old seats if necessary, and replace with new ones made of durable materials like brass or stainless steel for longer life.
Before reassembly, clean all components thoroughly and apply plumber's grease to threads and washers for easier installation and better sealing. Reinstall the stems, tightening them firmly but not excessively – overtightening can damage the valve seats and cause new leaks.
Sometimes faucet repairs don't go as smoothly as planned. After completing hundreds of these repairs, I've encountered nearly every possible complication. The most common issue is continued dripping after replacing washers or cartridges – this usually indicates worn valve seats that need replacement or reseating.
Stripped screw heads present another frequent challenge, especially on older faucets with years of mineral buildup. I recommend using a screw extractor tool for severely stripped screws, or applying penetrating oil and letting it sit for several hours before attempting removal again.
For handles that won't come off, try applying gentle heat with a hair dryer to expand the metal, then wiggle while pulling upward. Mineral buildup can be dissolved with white vinegar applied with a cloth around the handle base – let it sit for 30 minutes before attempting removal again.
If you've replaced all components and the faucet still leaks, the problem may be deeper in the plumbing system. Cracked valve bodies or deteriorated pipes behind the wall require professional intervention – these are situations where I recommend calling a plumber rather than risking water damage.
Another common issue is cross-connection between hot and cold lines, which can cause constant dripping regardless of handle position. This problem requires reconfiguring the supply lines and is best left to professionals unless you have significant plumbing experience.
For faucets that continue leaking around the base rather than from the spout, the issue may be worn O-rings on the valve body. These require complete faucet removal for replacement and present a good opportunity to upgrade to a new faucet unit if your current one is aging.
The financial benefits of DIY faucet repair are substantial. Based on my experience tracking repair costs across different regions, professional plumbers typically charge $200-400 for bathtub faucet repairs, including parts and labor. The same repair completed DIY usually costs $15-50 for parts, depending on the faucet type and quality of replacement components.
However, cost savings must be balanced against your skill level and available tools. If you need to purchase specialized tools for a one-time repair, the breakeven point shifts significantly. I recommend attempting DIY repairs if you have basic tools and some DIY experience, but calling professionals for complex situations or if you're uncomfortable with the process.
Time investment is another consideration. While I can complete most faucet repairs in 1-2 hours, beginners should plan for 3-4 hours including potential complications and trips to the hardware store. Factor in the value of your time when calculating true cost savings.
⏰ Time Saver: Keep a small container nearby for hardware removal – losing tiny screws and washers down the drain is the most common frustration during faucet repairs.
Preventive maintenance can extend the life of your faucet repairs significantly. I recommend cleaning aerators monthly to prevent mineral buildup, checking for small leaks weekly, and addressing drips immediately rather than waiting for them to worsen.
For homes with hard water, installing a water softener can dramatically extend faucet life by reducing mineral deposits that wear out internal components. Regular cleaning with vinegar solutions prevents buildup that can cause premature failure.
Keep records of your repairs, including part numbers and installation dates. This information proves invaluable when future repairs are needed, especially for determining warranty eligibility and matching replacement parts accurately.
Look at the number of handles – one handle indicates a cartridge faucet, while two handles indicate compression stems with washers. Take photos and remove the handle to see the internal mechanism before purchasing replacement parts.
If local shut-off valves don't work, you'll need to turn off the main water supply to your house. The main valve is typically located where water enters your home – in a basement, crawlspace, or exterior wall in warmer climates.
Professional repairs typically cost $200-400 including parts and labor. DIY repairs cost $15-50 for parts only, but factor in tool purchases if you don't already own basic plumbing tools.
Continued leaks usually indicate worn valve seats that the cartridge seals against. These may need replacement or reseating. Mineral buildup on the valve body can also prevent proper sealing and requires thorough cleaning.
Apply penetrating oil around the base and let it sit for several hours. Use gentle heat from a hair dryer to expand the metal, then wiggle while pulling upward. A handle puller tool can also help with particularly stubborn handles.
Call a professional if you can't shut off water completely, if the valve body is cracked, if pipes behind the wall are damaged, or if you're uncomfortable with the repair process. Water damage costs far exceed professional repair fees.
Fixing a leaky bathtub faucet is well within the capabilities of most homeowners with basic DIY skills. The satisfaction of completing the repair yourself, combined with significant cost savings, makes this one of the most rewarding home maintenance projects you can tackle.
Remember that prevention is always easier than repair – address small drips immediately rather than waiting for them to worsen. Regular maintenance and prompt attention to minor issues can extend your faucet's life by years and prevent costly water damage.
For related bathroom repair projects, check out our other DIY guides. And if you're considering upgrading your fixtures, explore our bathroom fixtures reviews to find the perfect replacements for your space.