Mooncat Nerf in Grow a Garden: New Shroomie Meta (September 2025)

The Moon Cat in Grow a Garden has received its biggest nerf in the game's history, removing the stacking ability that made it one of the most valuable pets for farming huge plants. This shadow nerf, implemented without official announcement, has completely changed the meta for late-game farming strategies. If you're wondering what happened to your Moon Cat setup and how to adapt, this comprehensive guide covers everything you need to know about the nerf, its impact, and the best alternatives available.

Pin it

Quick Facts: Moon Cat Nerf Summary

Aspect	Before Nerf	After Nerf
Stacking Ability	Multiple cats could stack effects	Only one cat effect applies
Plant Size Bonus	Up to 1.53x per cat (stackable)	1.5x maximum (non-stacking)
Fruit Duplication	100% chance with multiple cats	~6% base chance only
Pet Value	Extremely high (100M+ sheckles)	Significantly decreased
Meta Status	Best farming pet	Situationally useful

What Was the Moon Cat Method?

The Moon Cat method was arguably the most efficient farming strategy in Grow a Garden before the nerf. Here's how it worked:

Moon Cat's Original Abilities

• Nap Cycle: Every 70-90 seconds, the cat would nap for 15-20 seconds
• Size Bonus: Fruits within 15-20 studs radius grew 1.5x larger when starting growth during nap
• Replant Chance: 6% chance for night-type fruits to automatically replant after harvest
• Stacking Effect: Multiple cats could multiply these effects exponentially

Why It Was So Powerful?

The stacking mechanic was what made Moon Cats truly exceptional. Players discovered that by placing multiple Moon Cats (or Orange Tabby cats, which share the same ability) around the same plants, they could achieve:

• Massive size multipliers: With 8 cats, players could grow plants 12x larger than normal
• 100% duplication rates: The replant chance would stack to guarantee automatic replanting
• Passive income generation: Combined with sprinklers, players could go AFK and return to enormous harvests

This method was particularly effective for growing valuable crops like Bone Blossoms, Moon Melons, and other night-themed fruits that could sell for millions of sheckles per harvest.

The Great Nerf: What Changed in Patch 1883?

Official Confirmation vs. Shadow Update

The Moon Cat nerf is particularly controversial because it wasn't officially announced in any patch notes. According to the Grow a Garden Wiki and community testing, the changes were implemented silently in what players refer to as "Patch 1883" (though the official update log shows different version numbering).

Key Changes Implemented

• Stacking Removed: The most significant change is that cat nap abilities no longer stack. No matter how many Moon Cats or Orange Tabby cats you own, only one cat's effect will apply to any given plant.
• Size Bonus Capped: While individual cats still provide their 1.5x size bonus, you can no longer multiply this effect with multiple pets.
• Replant Chance Reset: The fruit duplication chance no longer stacks, returning to the base 6% regardless of how many cats you have.
• Version Confusion: The nerf appears to have been implemented in internal version v1618 (late July 2025) but wasn't widely noticed by players until September 2025, leading to confusion about when exactly the changes took effect.

Community Reaction

• The response from the Grow a Garden community has been overwhelmingly negative. Players who invested hundreds of millions of sheckles in acquiring multiple Moon Cats suddenly found their valuable pets significantly less useful.
• As one community member posted: "Moon cats are now useless. SO there basically worth nothing. I guess shroomies are the new meta T-T"
• Another player expressed frustration: "I hate that there is a big lack of transparency on their changes with the game. So many silent changes being done throughout the week."

Is This a Bug or Intended Nerf?

There's ongoing debate in the community about whether this change was intentional or a bug:

Evidence for Intentional Nerf

• The nerf addresses a clear balance issue where players could generate unlimited wealth
• Similar stacking abilities have been limited in other pets to prevent exploitation
• The change affects all cat-type pets with nap abilities, suggesting a systematic balance pass

Evidence for Potential Bug

• No official announcement or patch notes mention the change
• Some players report inconsistent behavior, suggesting it might be unintentional
• The timing and lack of communication are unusual for major balance changes

Developer Silence

Perhaps the most frustrating aspect for players is the lack of communication from the developers. As of September 2025, there has been no official statement confirming whether this was an intentional balance change or an unintended bug that will be fixed.

Impact on Different Playstyles

For New Players

If you're just starting Grow a Garden, the Moon Cat nerf actually has minimal impact. The Moon Cat method was primarily an end-game strategy that required significant investment in both pets and garden infrastructure.

For Mid-Game Players

Players who were saving up for their first Moon Cat may want to reconsider their investment. While still useful, a single Moon Cat no longer provides the game-changing advantages it once did.

For End-Game Players

This is where the nerf hits hardest. Players who had established elaborate Moon Cat farms with multiple pets and optimized layouts have seen their efficiency drop dramatically. Some report their income decreasing by 90% or more.

For Traders and Collectors

The trading market has been thrown into chaos. Moon Cats that were once valued at 100+ million sheckles have seen their value plummet, though they remain rare collectibles.

The New Meta: Shroomie Pet Alternative

With the Moon Cat method nerfed, players have been searching for alternatives, and the Shroomie pet has emerged as the new meta for large-scale farming.

Shroomie Pet Overview

• Obtained: Fairy Event (second half), now available through trading
• Rarity: Legendary
• Hunger: 20,000
• Added: September 6, 2025

How Shroomie Works?

The Shroomie's ability is fundamentally different from the Moon Cat's but can achieve similar results:Line Wrapping All nearby plants within ~15 studs will have increased 0.005x size bonus for every Fungus type plant in the player's garden! (Max 300)

Setting Up the Shroomie Method

• Plant Fungus Crops: You need up to 300 fungus-type plants in your garden
• Position Shroomies: Place Shroomie pets strategically to cover your main crops
• Stack Multiple Shroomies: Unlike Moon Cats, Shroomie abilities DO stack
• Max Bonus: With maximum setup, you can achieve 1.5x size bonus per Shroomie

Advantages Over Moon Cats

• Stacking Still Works: Multiple Shroomies multiply the effect
• No Timing Required: Unlike cat naps, the effect is constant
• Scalable: More fungus plants = bigger bonuses
• Future-Proof: No current indication of similar nerfs

Disadvantages

• Complex Setup: Requires planting and maintaining 300 fungus plants
• Resource Intensive: Fungus plants need space and maintenance
• Slower Start: Takes time to build up the fungus garden infrastructure

Other Viable Alternatives

Orange Tabby Cats

While also affected by the stacking nerf, Orange Tabby cats are more accessible and can still provide the 1.5x size bonus for players who prefer the cat method.

Triceratops and Echo Frogs

These pets work well with the remaining Moon Cat abilities by controlling growth timing and ensuring fruits start growing during nap periods.

Event-Specific Pets

Keep an eye on limited-time events, as new pets with stacking abilities may be introduced to fill the void left by the nerfed Moon Cats.

Adapting Your Current Moon Cat Setup

If you already have Moon Cats and want to make the best of the situation, here are some strategies:

Single Moon Cat Optimization

• Strategic Placement: Position your Moon Cat to cover your most valuable crops
• Timing Management: Plant crops to coincide with nap cycles
• Complementary Pets: Use pets that extend growth windows or automate planting

Hybrid Approaches

• Moon Cat + Shroomie: Use both pets for different crop types
• Specialized Gardens: Create separate areas for cat-optimized and fungus-optimized farming
• Diversified Portfolio: Don't rely on any single method for all your income

Economic Impact and Market Analysis in 2025

Pet Market Changes

The nerf has created a significant shift in the pet trading economy:

• Moon Cat Values: Down 60-80% from pre-nerf prices
• Shroomie Demand: Increased dramatically, prices rising
• Orange Tabby Market: Also affected but less severely due to lower initial cost

Resource Economy

Changes in farming efficiency have affected the broader game economy:

• Rare Fruit Prices: Increased due to reduced supply
• Fungus Seeds: Higher demand for Shroomie setups
• Sprinkler Market: Still strong for automated farming

Future Outlook and Predictions

Potential Reversals

There's a chance the developers could:

• Restore partial stacking with diminishing returns
• Introduce new abilities to compensate
• Provide official communication about the change

New Meta Developments

Watch for:

• New event pets with stacking mechanics
• Balance changes to other farming methods
• Community-discovered workarounds and optimizations

Community Resources and Official Channels

Official Resources

• Discord Server: Join the official Grow a Garden Discord for real-time discussions and developer announcements
• Twitter/X: Follow the official account for patch notes and event information
• Roblox Group: Stay updated with game news and community events

Community Resources

• Grow a Garden Wiki: Comprehensive information about all pets, items, and mechanics
• Reddit Community: r/growagarden for player discussions and strategy sharing
• YouTube Guides: Video tutorials for new farming methods and pet setups

Expert Tips and Strategies

For Maximum Efficiency

• Diversify Your Pets: Don't rely on a single pet type
• Stay Informed: Follow official channels for patch notes and changes
• Test New Methods: Experiment with different pet combinations
• Plan Long-Term: Consider future nerfs when making large investments

Common Mistakes to Avoid in 2025

• Overinvesting in One Method: The Moon Cat nerf shows the risk of putting all resources into a single strategy
• Ignoring Community Feedback: Other players often discover changes before they're officially announced
• Neglecting Alternative Setups: Always have backup plans for your farming operations

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Was the Moon Cat nerf intentional?

A: While not officially confirmed, the nerf appears to be intentional based on how systematically it was implemented across all cat-type pets. However, the lack of official communication leaves room for doubt.

Q: Can I still use my Moon Cats effectively?

A: Yes, but you'll need to adapt your strategy. A single Moon Cat still provides a 1.5x size bonus and 6% replant chance, but you won't get the exponential benefits of stacking multiple cats.

Q: What's the best alternative to the Moon Cat method?

A: The Shroomie pet method is currently considered the best alternative, as it allows stacking effects and can achieve similar or better results with proper setup.

Q: Will Moon Cats regain their value?

A: It's unlikely Moon Cats will return to their pre-nerf value unless the stacking ability is restored. However, they may retain some value as rare collectibles and for their remaining utility.

Q: How can I stay updated on future changes?

A: Join the official Discord server, follow the game's social media accounts, and participate in community discussions to stay informed about updates and changes.

Q: Should I sell my Moon Cats now?

A: This depends on your individual situation. If you need the sheckles for other investments and don't use the cats anymore, selling might be wise. However, holding onto them as rare collectibles could be a good long-term strategy.

Q: Are there any workarounds for the stacking nerf?

A: Currently, there are no known workarounds that restore the stacking ability. The community is actively testing different setups, but nothing has been found that replicates the old Moon Cat method's effectiveness.

Conclusion

The Moon Cat nerf represents one of the most significant balance changes in Grow a Garden's history, fundamentally altering late-game farming strategies. While frustrating for players who invested heavily in the Moon Cat method, the change has opened up new opportunities with pets like the Shroomie and encouraged more diverse farming approaches.

As the game continues to evolve, staying adaptable and informed will be key to success. Whether you choose to optimize your remaining Moon Cats, switch to the Shroomie method, or develop entirely new strategies, the dynamic nature of Grow a Garden ensures there will always be new challenges and opportunities to explore.

Keep experimenting, stay connected with the community, and most importantly, enjoy your garden! The meta may change, but the core satisfaction of growing and harvesting your virtual crops remains the same.