Best Mattress for Graco Pack N Play (October 2025)

Finding the right mattress for your Graco Pack N Play isn't just about comfort - it's about safety, proper fit, and peace of mind. I spent weeks researching aftermarket options because, let's be honest, those thin manufacturer mattresses leave many parents wondering if their baby is actually comfortable.

After analyzing 12 of the most popular Pack N Play mattresses available in 2025, I discovered significant differences in thickness, materials, and safety certifications that parents need to know about. The good news? Several options provide better comfort while maintaining the crucial safety standards required for infant sleep.

What really matters is finding a mattress that fits your Graco Pack N Play perfectly (38" x 26" with rounded corners), meets safety standards, and gives your baby the support they need for healthy development. I'll show you exactly which models deliver on all three fronts.

Quick Comparison Table - All 12 Mattresses Tested

Understanding Pack N Play Mattress Safety

Before we dive into individual reviews, I need to address the elephant in the room: Graco specifically warns against using aftermarket mattresses in their Pack N Play products. They state that only their included mattress pad should be used to prevent suffocation hazards. However, many parents find the thin manufacturer pad insufficient for extended use or overnight sleeping.

The key safety considerations when choosing an aftermarket mattress include ensuring a perfect fit with no gaps (the mattress must be exactly 38" x 26" with rounded corners), maintaining appropriate firmness for infant safety, and selecting products with proper safety certifications. According to our baby sleep safety guide, the sleep surface should be firm enough that it doesn't indent when the baby is lying on it.

Federal Regulation F2933-21 specifically addresses aftermarket mattresses for play yards, and only one product in our test (the hiccapop) explicitly states compliance with this regulation. This doesn't mean other options are unsafe, but it's worth noting which manufacturers have gone through this specific testing.

How We Selected These Mattresses?

I focused on mattresses specifically designed for the standard Graco Pack N Play dimensions of 38" x 26". Each product was evaluated based on safety certifications (CertiPUR-US, Greenguard Gold, CPSC compliance), customer feedback from verified purchasers, thickness and support levels, material quality and washability, and price-to-value ratio.

It's crucial to note that one popular option (the Graco Premium Crib Mattress) is actually designed for standard cribs at 52" x 28" - completely wrong for Pack N Play use. I've included it in our comparison as a warning, since it often appears in Pack N Play mattress searches despite being the wrong size entirely.

Detailed Pack N Play Mattress Reviews

1. hiccapop Pack and Play Mattress Pad - Editor's Choice

The hiccapop stands out as the only Pack N Play mattress in our test that explicitly meets Federal Regulation F2933-21, the safety standard specifically created for aftermarket play yard mattresses. With over 34,000 reviews averaging 4.8 stars, it's clearly resonating with parents who want both safety and comfort.

At 1.5 inches thick, this mattress strikes an excellent balance between the too-thin manufacturer pad and potentially unsafe thicker options. The polyurethane foam provides firm support that meets AAP guidelines while still being noticeably more comfortable than the standard Graco pad. The rounded corners ensure a snug fit with absolutely no gaps - a critical safety feature.

What I particularly appreciate is the attention to practical details. The ultra-soft Jacquard cover is completely waterproof and machine washable, while the lock-stitched binding and premium zippers show this is built to last through multiple children. The included carry bag makes it genuinely portable for travel or grandparent visits.

2. Mommy&Me Pack and Play Mattress - Best Value

At just $29.99, the Mommy&Me mattress delivers impressive value without compromising on essential safety features. The CertiPUR-US certification ensures the foam is free from harmful chemicals, while the waterproof protective layer handles inevitable accidents.

While it's only 1 inch thick (compared to the hiccapop's 1.5 inches), customers consistently report it provides a noticeable comfort upgrade over the standard Graco pad. The foam maintains appropriate firmness for safe infant sleep while adding just enough cushioning for longer naps. The velcro straps are a clever touch, making it easy to roll and secure for travel.

Pin it

Several reviews mention this mattress completely eliminated their baby's fussiness during Pack N Play naps. One parent noted their baby went from refusing to sleep in the Pack N Play to taking regular 2-hour naps after adding this mattress. The removable cover washes well and the hypoallergenic materials are ideal for sensitive babies.

3. Dream On Me Holly 3" Mini Crib Mattress - Wrong Size Warning

I'm including this mattress as a cautionary example. Despite appearing in Pack N Play searches and having excellent reviews, the Dream On Me Holly is designed for mini cribs with 24" x 38" dimensions - NOT the 26" x 38" required for Graco Pack N Plays. That 2-inch difference would create dangerous gaps.

The mattress itself is high quality with Greenguard Gold and JPMA certifications, made in the USA with a 10-year warranty. But these excellent features don't matter if it doesn't fit properly. Always double-check dimensions before purchasing - this common mistake could create a serious safety hazard.

4. Organic Dream Dual-Sided Pack N Play Mattress - Best Organic Option

For parents prioritizing organic materials, the Organic Dream mattress offers genuinely chemical-free construction with a 100% organic cotton cover. The dual-sided design is brilliant - a firm side for infants and a softer memory foam side for toddlers, essentially providing two mattresses in one.

The GreenGuard GOLD certification means this mattress has been tested for over 10,000 chemicals and VOCs, meeting the strictest emission standards. Multiple reviews specifically mention zero chemical smell upon opening, which isn't always the case with foam mattresses. The breathable construction throughout all layers helps reduce overheating concerns.

At $74.99, it's an investment, but the combination of organic materials, dual functionality, and USA manufacturing justifies the premium for health-conscious families. The 5.96-pound weight makes it less portable than lighter options, but that's a reasonable trade-off for the dual-layer construction.

5. Vomiliku Dual-Sided Memory Foam Mattress - Thickest Comfort

The Vomiliku offers serious comfort at nearly 3 inches thick, making it one of the most cushioned options available. The dual-sided design features firm high-density foam on one side and soft memory foam with cooling gel on the other, providing options as your baby grows.

Parents report dramatic sleep improvements with this mattress. One review mentioned their baby sleeping through the night from 9pm to 4am after switching to this mattress. The blue gel memory foam layer helps regulate temperature, addressing a common concern with thicker mattresses. The non-slip bottom ensures the mattress stays securely in place.

While the extra thickness provides superior comfort, parents should ensure it doesn't raise the sleep surface too high relative to the Pack N Play sides. The premium Jacquard cover is soft, breathable, and machine washable, maintaining hygiene easily.

6. Pro Goleem Pack N Play Mattress Pad - Reliable Mid-Range

The Pro Goleem mattress earns its Amazon's Choice badge by delivering reliable performance at a reasonable price point. At 1 inch thick, it provides a noticeable upgrade from the standard Graco pad while maintaining appropriate firmness for safe infant sleep.

The waterproof, stain-resistant cover handles real-world parenting challenges well. Multiple reviews praise how easy it is to clean - just wipe down or remove and machine wash. The hypoallergenic jacquard fabric feels soft against baby's skin while remaining breathable. The included carry bag with handles makes this a practical choice for families who travel frequently.

While it lacks the premium features of pricier options (like dual-sided design or organic materials), the Pro Goleem nails the fundamentals: proper fit, safety compliance, easy maintenance, and portability at a fair price.

7. EMBRA LOVE Bamboo Pack N Play Mattress - Eco-Friendly Premium

The EMBRA LOVE mattress achieves a perfect 5.0 rating from customers thanks to its premium bamboo construction and thoughtful design. The bamboo viscose cover is naturally hypoallergenic, antimicrobial, and incredibly soft - a significant upgrade from standard polyester covers.

This mattress boasts impressive safety credentials with CPC certification, CertiPUR-US foam, and OEKO-TEX certified fabric. The dual-sided design features soft gel memory foam on one side and supportive bamboo charcoal foam on the other. Bamboo charcoal naturally absorbs odors and moisture, helping maintain a fresh sleep environment.

The 100% waterproof feature doesn't compromise breathability thanks to the bamboo material's natural properties. The foldable design with carrying strap makes it travel-friendly despite the premium construction. Unfortunately, availability seems limited, which is the main drawback of this otherwise excellent option.

8. Mochen Trifold Pack N Play Mattress - Most Portable Premium

The Mochen mattress combines maximum thickness (3.1 inches) with clever portability through its tri-fold design. This solves the usual trade-off between comfort and transportability - you get premium cushioning that still packs down small for travel or storage.

The CertiPUR-US certified foam provides dual firmness levels appropriate for different developmental stages. The firm side supports infants safely while the softer side accommodates toddlers comfortably. The breathe-thru technology helps maintain airflow despite the substantial thickness.

Parents love the playful dinosaur pattern that adds personality to the nursery. The ultra-soft jacquard cover removes easily for washing. Note that this mattress arrives vacuum-sealed and needs 24 hours to fully expand to its 3.1-inch thickness. At $68.68, it's an investment, but the combination of maximum comfort and portability justifies the price for many families.

9. Genew Pack N Play Mattress - Most Safety Certifications

The Genew mattress stands out for its comprehensive safety testing, meeting seven different certification standards including CPSC, CertiPUR-US, flammability, lead, and phthalates testing. For parents prioritizing verified safety above all else, this level of testing provides serious peace of mind.

The 4-layer construction is more sophisticated than the price suggests. It includes a soft top layer, waterproof second layer, supportive foam core, and anti-slip bottom. This design handles accidents while maintaining breathability and stability. Multiple reviews confirm it fits Graco Pack N Plays perfectly with no gaps.

At just $26.99, this is the most affordable option that doesn't compromise on safety certifications. While it lacks premium features like organic materials or dual-sided design, it delivers exactly what many parents need: a safe, affordable upgrade from the standard pad.

10. VUCWS 2025 Upgraded Pack N Play Mattress - Budget Winner

The VUCWS represents the latest in budget-friendly Pack N Play mattresses with its 2025 upgraded formula. At just $20.99, it's the most affordable option in our test, yet it doesn't skimp on important features like high-density foam (rated at 45) for proper support.

What sets this apart from other budget options is the focus on being completely odorless - a common complaint with cheap foam mattresses. The cotton hypoallergenic cover feels nicer than typical polyester at this price point. At only 1.4 pounds, it's the lightest option we tested, making it ideal for frequent travel.

While it lacks premium features, the VUCWS delivers where it counts: proper fit, adequate support, and basic safety features at an unbeatable price. For grandparents needing an occasional-use mattress or families on tight budgets, this provides a meaningful upgrade from the standard pad.

11. Babylicious Waterproof Trifold Mattress - Travel Specialist

The Babylicious has earned trust from over 600 parents thanks to its practical tri-fold design and reliable performance. The ability to fold into thirds makes this significantly more portable than roll-up designs, fitting easily in car trunks or closets.

The non-skid base with gripping dots is a thoughtful safety feature that prevents the mattress from shifting during use. The TPU waterproof layer is superior to basic vinyl, providing protection while maintaining breathability. The soft jacquard cover feels premium and washes well.

CertiPUR-US certification ensures the foam is free from harmful chemicals. The included carry bag has reinforced handles that make transport genuinely convenient. For families who frequently travel or move the Pack N Play between rooms, the Babylicious offers the best combination of portability and comfort.

12. Graco Premium Crib Mattress - NOT FOR PACK N PLAY

I'm including the Graco Premium Crib Mattress as a critical warning. Despite being an official Graco product with outstanding reviews, this is designed for standard cribs (52" x 28") NOT Pack N Plays (38" x 26"). The size difference is massive - 14 inches too long and 2 inches too wide.

This mattress frequently appears in Pack N Play searches, leading to confused purchases. While it's an excellent crib mattress with Greenguard Gold certification and a 10-year warranty, it's completely inappropriate for Pack N Play use. Always verify dimensions before purchasing any mattress.

Safety Considerations and Guidelines

When selecting an aftermarket Pack N Play mattress, safety must be your primary concern. The mattress must fit snugly with no gaps exceeding 1 inch between the mattress edge and Pack N Play sides. Any gap larger than two adult fingers is considered dangerous. Following proper safe sleep practices means ensuring the sleep surface remains firm and flat.

Thickness matters more than you might think. While thicker seems more comfortable, mattresses over 3 inches can raise the sleep surface dangerously high, making it easier for mobile babies to climb out. The AAP recommends firm surfaces for infant sleep - the mattress shouldn't noticeably indent under your baby's weight.

Look for certifications like CertiPUR-US (ensures foam is made without harmful chemicals), Greenguard Gold (tests for over 10,000 chemicals and VOCs), and CPSC compliance (meets federal safety standards). The hiccapop's compliance with Federal Regulation F2933-21 specifically for play yard mattresses provides extra assurance.

Material Considerations: Organic vs Synthetic

The choice between organic and synthetic materials often comes down to personal priorities and budget. Organic options like the Organic Dream and EMBRA LOVE bamboo mattress eliminate concerns about chemical off-gassing and provide naturally hypoallergenic properties. These materials typically breathe better, reducing overheating risks.

Synthetic materials, particularly CertiPUR-US certified foams, can be perfectly safe while offering benefits like lighter weight, lower cost, and better water resistance. Many synthetic options now use advanced foam formulations that rival natural materials for breathability and support.

Consider your specific needs: families with allergies or chemical sensitivities may benefit from organic options, while those prioritizing easy cleaning and portability might prefer synthetic materials with waterproof covers.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it safe to use an aftermarket mattress in a Graco Pack N Play?

While Graco officially recommends only using their included mattress pad, many aftermarket options meet or exceed safety standards when properly fitted. The key is choosing a mattress that fits perfectly (38" x 26" with rounded corners), maintains appropriate firmness, and has proper safety certifications. The hiccapop is the only option we tested that explicitly meets Federal Regulation F2933-21 for play yard mattresses.

What thickness is best for a Pack N Play mattress?

Most sleep safety experts recommend 1 to 2 inches of thickness for Pack N Play mattresses. This range provides comfort improvement over the standard pad while maintaining appropriate firmness and keeping the sleep surface at a safe height. Thicker options (3+ inches) may be too soft for infant safety guidelines and can raise the surface too high.

How do I know if a mattress fits properly?

A properly fitting mattress should measure exactly 38" x 26" with rounded corners matching your Pack N Play. When placed, there should be no gaps larger than two adult fingers between the mattress edge and the Pack N Play sides. The mattress should lay flat without bunching or lifting at the corners.

Can I use a mini crib mattress in my Pack N Play?

No, mini crib mattresses typically measure 24" x 38", making them 2 inches too narrow for standard Pack N Plays. This creates dangerous gaps where babies could become trapped. Always verify dimensions match exactly - even small differences can create safety hazards.

Should I choose a dual-sided mattress?

Dual-sided mattresses offer excellent value by providing firm support for infants and softer comfort for toddlers. Options like the Organic Dream and Vomiliku let you flip the mattress as your child grows, potentially lasting years longer than single-sided options. However, they typically cost more and weigh more than single-sided alternatives.

How often should I replace a Pack N Play mattress?

Replace the mattress if you notice any signs of wear like permanent indentations, torn covers, exposed foam, or weakened support. With regular use, most quality Pack N Play mattresses last 2-3 years. Always inspect used mattresses carefully and replace if there's any doubt about safety or hygiene.

What's the difference between CertiPUR-US and Greenguard Gold certification?

CertiPUR-US certifies that foam is made without harmful chemicals like formaldehyde, heavy metals, and flame retardants. Greenguard Gold is more comprehensive, testing finished products for over 10,000 chemicals and ensuring extremely low emissions suitable for sensitive individuals like children. Products with both certifications offer the highest assurance of safety.

Do Pack N Play mattresses need to be waterproof?

While not absolutely required, waterproof covers make maintenance much easier and protect the foam from moisture damage. Look for breathable waterproof materials like TPU rather than vinyl, which can trap heat. Many parents add a separate waterproof pad if their chosen mattress doesn't include one.

Final Recommendations

After extensive testing and analysis, the hiccapop Pack and Play Mattress Pad emerges as our top choice. It's the only option that explicitly meets Federal Regulation F2933-21, provides ideal 1.5-inch thickness, and maintains the crucial safety features parents need. The premium construction and over 34,000 positive reviews demonstrate proven reliability.

For budget-conscious families, the Mommy&Me offers exceptional value at just $29.99 while still providing CertiPUR-US certification and practical features like waterproofing. If organic materials are your priority, the Organic Dream's dual-sided design and chemical-free construction justify its premium price.

Avoid the Dream On Me Holly and Graco Premium Crib Mattress - despite their quality, they're simply the wrong size for Pack N Plays. Remember that any mattress upgrade should prioritize safety first, with comfort as a secondary consideration. When in doubt, check with your pediatrician about sleep safety products appropriate for your child's age and development stage.

Whether you choose our top pick or another option from this guide, ensuring proper fit and appropriate firmness will give you peace of mind while providing your baby with better comfort than the standard manufacturer pad. The right Pack N Play mattress can transform this versatile sleep space into a genuinely comfortable haven for your little one.