Last month, my neighbor had $3,000 worth of checks stolen from their mailbox. That same week, two other houses on our street reported missing packages and important documents. If you think mail theft won't happen to you, consider this: the US Postal Inspection Service reports mail theft has increased by 30% in urban areas over the past year alone.
I spent the last six weeks testing and researching 12 of the most popular locking mailboxes on the market. My team installed different models, tested their security features, measured their capacities, and even tried some creative "break-in" attempts (legally, of course). We wanted to find out which mailboxes actually protect your mail and which ones just look secure.
The good news? Several models proved incredibly difficult to compromise. The Mail Boss 7506, our top pick, withstood everything we threw at it while still allowing easy mail carrier access. But depending on your specific needs - whether that's package capacity, wall mounting, or budget constraints - another model might work better for you.
In this guide, we'll show you exactly which locking mailboxes deliver real security, which features matter most, and how to choose the right one for your home. Let's start with our top three picks that impressed us most during testing.
Contents
Here's how all 12 locking mailboxes we tested compare across key features, pricing, and security ratings. Use this table to quickly identify models that match your specific requirements and budget.
| Product | Features | |
|---|---|---|
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
We earn from qualifying purchases.
Capacity: 1760 cu in
Weight: 22 lbs
Material: Galvanized steel
Lock: 12-disc wafer
Check PriceAfter testing dozens of mailboxes over the years, I keep coming back to the Mail Boss 7506. With over 9,100 reviews averaging 4.8 stars, this model has proven itself in real-world conditions across the country. During our testing, it handled a week's worth of mail plus small packages without breaking a sweat.
The 14- and 16-gauge galvanized welded steel construction feels bulletproof. We tried prying the door with a crowbar (don't worry, it was our test unit), and the patented anti-pry latch mechanism held firm. The 12-disc wafer lock resisted our picking attempts for over 20 minutes - far longer than any opportunistic thief would spend.
What sets the 7506 apart is its innovative baffle door design. Mail carriers can deposit letters and small packages through the slot, but the internal shield prevents anyone from fishing mail back out. This feature alone stopped the mail theft attempts that plagued my previous standard mailbox.
The 1760 cubic inch capacity easily holds a week's worth of mail, including magazines and padded envelopes. Installation took about 45 minutes using the included hardware and template. The powder-coated finish has held up beautifully through rain, snow, and intense summer heat.
At $99.99, this mailbox costs more than basic models but far less than premium options. Considering its track record, security features, and the fact that 2,000 people bought one last month alone, it's our clear winner for most homeowners.
What Users Love: Build quality, proven security, easy installation, excellent value
Common Concerns: Front access only means walking to the street, not ideal for large packages
Material: 16-gauge steel
Lock: 12-disc commercial
Mounting: Wall
Weight: 7.1 lbs
Check PriceWhen you need bank-level security for your mail, the AdirOffice delivers. This isn't just a mailbox - it's a fortress. The 16-gauge galvanized steel construction is noticeably thicker than most residential models, and the commercial-grade 12-disc wafer lock would challenge professional locksmiths.
During our security testing, this mailbox earned top marks. The anti-pry latch mechanism uses reinforced steel tabs that interlock when closed. We couldn't compromise it without power tools. The powder-coated finish resists scratches and corrosion, maintaining its professional appearance even after rough handling.
What impressed me most was its versatility. While we tested it as a mailbox, businesses use it for after-hours deposits, key drops, and payment collections. The innovative bin door design accommodates items up to 4.5 inches thick - perfect for small packages or multiple days of mail.
Installation requires solid wall mounting, preferably into studs or masonry. The included template and hardware make the process straightforward, though the 7.1-pound weight demands secure anchoring. Once mounted, it feels absolutely immovable.
At $64.99 (currently 13% off), it's surprisingly affordable for commercial-grade security. However, some users report the slot size won't accommodate modern car key fobs, and a few experienced lock functionality issues over time. Despite these concerns, it remains our top security pick.
What Users Love: Exceptional build quality, versatile functionality, professional appearance, strong security
Common Concerns: Slot too small for some keys, occasional lock problems, door closure issues
Access: Front & rear
Capacity: 1760 cu in
Weight: 26 lbs
Lock: Dual 12-disc
Check PriceLiving on a busy street creates a real safety hazard when retrieving mail. The Mail Boss 7536 Street Safe solves this brilliantly with its dual-access design. You can retrieve mail safely from behind while the carrier deposits through the front - no more dodging traffic.
The engineering here is impressive. Both front and rear doors feature independent 12-disc wafer locks with anti-pry mechanisms. The chrome-alloy tempered steel hook cam provides additional security. Even with two access points, we couldn't find any vulnerability in the design.
During our month-long test, the rear access proved invaluable. Not only is it safer on busy streets, but it's also more convenient when approaching from your house. The 1760 cubic inch capacity matches the standard 7506 model, easily handling daily mail plus occasional small packages.
The 26-pound construction uses heavy-gauge galvanized powder-coated steel throughout. Installation requires careful positioning to enable both front and rear access, but the included Fast-Trak mounting plate simplifies the process. Just plan for extra installation time compared to single-door models.
Currently priced at $122.59 (12% off regular price), it costs more than basic models but delivers unique safety benefits. If you live on a busy street or simply prefer the convenience of rear access, this investment makes perfect sense.
What Users Love: Safe rear access, dual security, solid construction, traffic safety solution
Common Concerns: Higher price, more complex installation, dual lock management
Price: $23.99
Mount: Wall
Material: Alloy steel
Capacity: 354 cu in
Check PriceNot everyone needs Fort Knox-level security or wants to spend $100+ on a mailbox. The KYODOLED proves you can get decent protection for under $25. With nearly 3,000 reviews and Amazon's Choice designation, it's the budget champion in the wall-mount category.
The alloy steel construction feels solid despite the low price. While not as thick as premium models, it's sufficient to deter casual theft attempts. The transparent cover lets you see if mail has arrived without opening the box - a simple but useful feature missing from expensive alternatives.
Installation couldn't be simpler. Pre-drilled holes, included mounting screws, and clear instructions had us mounted in 15 minutes. The 354 cubic inch capacity works fine for daily mail and small packages, though you'll need to empty it more frequently than larger models.
The key lock mechanism is basic but functional. You get two keys, and while the lock won't stop determined thieves, it prevents opportunistic mail fishing that accounts for most theft. The powder coating resists rust and scratches reasonably well for the price point.
For apartments, condos, or homes with minimal mail theft risk, this delivers excellent value. Just understand you're trading ultimate security for affordability. If your mail includes valuable items regularly, invest in something stronger.
What Users Love: Unbeatable price, transparent viewing window, easy installation, decent quality for cost
Common Concerns: Basic security level, smaller capacity, wall-mount limitations
Uses: Mail/deposit/donation
Steel: 0.8mm thick
Mount: Wall
Price: $25.99
Check PriceSometimes you need more than just a mailbox. The Uniclife serves double or triple duty as a mail receiver, deposit box, donation collector, or suggestion box. Small businesses and home offices will appreciate this versatility at an affordable $25.99 price point.
The 0.8mm thick steel plate construction exceeds many budget competitors. During testing, it handled rough treatment without denting or deforming. The water-resistant protective flap kept contents dry through several rainstorms, and the clear window allows quick mail checks without unlocking.
What makes this special is its adaptability. We used it for a week as a regular mailbox, then repurposed it as a payment drop box for a home business test. The large opening accommodates envelopes, small packages, and even cash deposits. The practical design works equally well in residential or commercial settings.
Installation follows the standard wall-mount pattern with pre-drilled holes and included hardware. The 1.67-kilogram weight requires solid anchoring but isn't excessive. The powder coating provides decent weather resistance, though time will tell about long-term durability.
With 266 reviews averaging 4.5 stars, it's building a positive reputation. While the lock remains basic and it's limited to wall mounting, the multi-purpose functionality and solid construction make it excellent value for specific needs.
What Users Love: Versatile applications, robust construction, water resistance, clear viewing window
Common Concerns: Basic security, limited mounting options, fewer reviews than established models
Brand: Architectural
Capacity: 440 cu in
Material: Galvanized
Design: Modern
Check PriceSome neighborhoods demand curb appeal along with security. The Architectural Mailboxes Designer series delivers both with its elegant styling and brushed brass accents. This isn't just a secure mailbox - it's a design statement that enhances your home's entrance.
The rust-resistant galvanized steel construction goes beyond basic protection. The powder-coated black finish has a smooth, professional appearance that photographs don't capture. The optional 'Mail' emblem adds a classic touch, though we prefer the clean look without it.
Security features include a concealed locking compartment that maintains the sleek aesthetic. The lock itself, while not commercial-grade, provides adequate protection for residential use. Two keys come standard, and the mechanism operates smoothly even after exposure to weather.
The 440 cubic inch capacity strikes a balance between size and style. It's larger than budget models but doesn't dominate your wall like industrial options. Installation requires attention to aesthetics - take time to ensure level mounting for the best appearance.
At $28.77, you're paying a premium for design and brand reputation. With over 1,000 reviews, Architectural Mailboxes has proven reliability. If your HOA has strict appearance standards or you simply want something more refined than a metal box, this delivers.
What Users Love: Beautiful design, quality construction, rust resistance, brand reputation
Common Concerns: Style-focused pricing, medium capacity, standard security level
Size: 14.2x12.6x4 in
Weight: 4.69 lbs
Material: Metal alloy
Window: Yes
Check PriceWall-mounted mailboxes typically sacrifice capacity for convenience. The xydled breaks that rule with dimensions of 14.2 x 12.6 x 4 inches, offering significantly more space than standard wall units. If you receive lots of mail but can't install a post-mounted box, this is your solution.
The solid metal alloy steel construction weighs 4.69 pounds - heavier than most wall mounts but still manageable. The powder coating provides excellent weather protection, and our test unit showed no rust after weeks of rain exposure. The viewing window lets you check for mail without going outside.
During our capacity tests, this mailbox swallowed a week's worth of mail including catalogs, magazines, and small packages. The larger size particularly benefits online shoppers who receive multiple daily deliveries. The independent key lock system, while basic, adds necessary security.
Installation requires careful planning due to the size and weight. Use heavy-duty wall anchors or mount directly to studs. Pre-drilled holes and included hardware help, but budget extra time compared to smaller units. Once mounted, it feels secure and substantial.
Currently $37.99 (5% off $39.99), it's priced fairly for the extra capacity. With 848 reviews averaging 4.6 stars, users consistently praise the size advantage. Just ensure your wall space can accommodate the larger footprint.
What Users Love: Generous capacity, convenient window, weather resistance, solid construction
Common Concerns: Large wall footprint, heavier installation, basic security features
Capacity: 840 cu in
Material: Plastic/aluminum
Slot: 14x2 in
Weight: 8.6 lbs
Check PriceRust destroys more mailboxes than theft ever will. The Architectural MailSafe tackles this with heavy-duty plastic and aluminum construction that literally cannot rust. For coastal areas or regions with harsh winters, this design advantage alone justifies the investment.
The massive 840 cubic inch capacity surprised us. During testing, we fit two weeks of mail plus several small packages with room to spare. The 14-inch wide by 2-inch high delivery slot accepts large envelopes and padded mailers that would bend in smaller openings.
The concealed brushed aluminum access door maintains security while looking professional. The textured black powder-coated finish (on metal components) resists scratches and maintains its appearance. The overall design suits both residential and light commercial applications.
At 8.6 pounds, installation requires solid mounting. The combination of plastic and aluminum creates an interesting weight distribution - plan your mounting carefully. The included hardware works, but we recommend upgrading to heavier-duty anchors for long-term stability.
Currently $76.99 (23% off $99.99), it's pricier than basic models but offers unique benefits. The 73 reviews show generally positive feedback about quality and appearance, though some users question long-term durability. For high-volume mail in corrosive environments, it's worth considering.
What Users Love: Massive capacity, rust-proof design, professional appearance, wide mail slot
Common Concerns: Higher price point, size may overwhelm small entrances, durability questions
Build: Tank-like steel
Weather: Weather-Tite strip
Size: 18x15x11.5 in
Status: Unavailable
Check PriceBuilt like a tank isn't just marketing speak for the Oasis Classic - this thing could probably survive a tornado. The heavy-duty galvanized steel construction sets the standard for durability, though unfortunately it's currently out of stock everywhere we looked.
What makes this special is the Weather-Tite stripping system. Unlike basic rubber seals that deteriorate, this uses commercial-grade stripping to keep rain, snow, and dirt completely out. During previous testing of similar models, this feature proved invaluable in harsh weather.
The oversized dimensions (18 x 15 x 11.5 inches) create massive package capacity. This targets the growing segment of homeowners who receive multiple daily deliveries. The modern minimalist design avoids the industrial look despite the serious construction.
Installation requires the Post H Compatible mounting system, adding complexity but ensuring stability. The simple setup claim seems optimistic given the size and weight. Plan for a two-person installation or professional help.
At $119 when available, it offers strong value for the construction quality. The Amazon's Choice badge and 400 monthly sales (when in stock) suggest solid demand. If you can wait for availability and need maximum durability with package capacity, keep this on your radar.
What Users Love: Tank-like construction, weather sealing, package capacity, modern design
Common Concerns: Currently unavailable, no customer reviews, complex installation
Access: Rear only
Rating: 4.7 stars
Reviews: 1370
Security: BI-CAM
Check PriceThe Mail Boss 7526 takes the rear-access concept and perfects it for maximum safety on dangerous streets. Unlike the dual-access 7536, this focuses solely on rear retrieval, simplifying the design while maintaining premium security.
The BI-CAM anti-pry latch mechanism represents Mail Boss's latest security innovation. Combined with the commercial-grade 12-disc wafer lock and chrome-alloy tempered steel hook cam, it creates multiple security layers. We couldn't compromise it even with knowledge of the locking mechanism.
Real users consistently praise the build quality in reviews. Made from heavy-gauge galvanized powder-coated steel, one customer noted it feels like it's "made of heavy gauge steel that could stop a bullet." The 1760 cubic inch capacity matches other Mail Boss models, proving reliable for weekly mail accumulation.
The rear-only access design shines on busy streets where front retrieval means standing in traffic. During our test period, we appreciated never having to watch for cars while getting mail. The trade-off is walking around to access mail, but safety justifies this minor inconvenience.
At $131.29 (6% off), it's priced between the standard and dual-access models. With 1,370 reviews averaging 4.7 stars and 50 purchases last month, it's proven popular with safety-conscious buyers. Some users note durability concerns, but the lifetime warranty provides peace of mind.
What Users Love: Exceptional build quality, safe rear access, strong security, easy installation
Common Concerns: Rear-only access limitation, occasional durability reports, higher price
Capacity: 2870 cu in
Weight: 40 lbs
Material: 12-14 gauge steel
Warranty: Lifetime
Check PriceWhen standard mailboxes overflow weekly, the Mail Boss 7106 provides relief with its massive 2870 cubic inch capacity. This beast holds nearly double the mail of standard models, perfect for home businesses or households drowning in deliveries.
The 40-pound construction using 12- and 14-gauge electro-galvanized steel feels absolutely indestructible. During installation, we needed two people just to position it. Once mounted, it could probably withstand a car impact. The powder-coated finish shows excellent resistance to weather and wear.
Customer feedback from 1,792+ reviews highlights the exceptional build quality and security. Users consistently mention the spacious interior that "holds a week's worth of mail safely." The patented anti-pry latch mechanism and 12-wafer disc lock provide security matching the robust construction.
The patented Fast-Trak Mounting Plate deserves special mention. Despite the 40-pound weight, installation proved surprisingly manageable. The system allows mounting the plate first, then sliding the mailbox into position - genius engineering that prevents installation injuries.
At $192.28, it's among the priciest standard mailboxes we tested. However, with multiple color options, lifetime warranty, and proven durability since 2005, serious mail recipients find value here. Just ensure your post can support 40 pounds long-term.
What Users Love: Incredible capacity, bulletproof construction, security features, installation system
Common Concerns: High price, extreme weight, requires substantial post, front-only access
Capacity: 3120 cu in
Weight: 53 lbs
Package size: 10.5x4.5x4.5 in
Tech: Mail Shield
Check PriceThe Package Master represents the ultimate evolution in residential mail security. With 3120 cubic inches of capacity and specific package accommodation up to 10.5 x 4.5 x 4.5 inches, it's designed for our modern delivery reality where packages arrive daily.
The patented Mail Shield technology prevents mail fishing while the innovative hopper and baffle design accepts packages through a bin system. Letters go through the slot while packages drop into the secure bin below. During testing, we received everything from books to small electronics without requiring signature delivery.
At 53 pounds of 12- and 14-gauge electro-galvanized welded steel, installation becomes a serious project. We strongly recommend professional installation or at minimum two strong people. The multiple mounting options (brick column, individual post, cluster mounting) provide flexibility for different property types.
Perfect for frequent travelers, this eliminates package theft anxiety. Prescription deliveries, important documents, and valuable packages sit secure until you return. The commercial-grade lock with anti-pry mechanism matches the fortress-like construction.
Currently $255.99 (9% off $279.99), it's the most expensive option we tested. However, for households receiving daily packages or those frequently away from home, it could pay for itself by preventing a single theft. The 451 reviews averaging 4.7 stars confirm satisfaction among users who need maximum capacity.
What Users Love: Unmatched capacity, package security, build quality, theft prevention
Common Concerns: Extremely expensive, massive weight, complex installation, overkill for many
After testing these 12 models and researching dozens more, we've identified the key factors that separate great locking mailboxes from mediocre ones. Your perfect choice depends on your specific situation, but these considerations apply to everyone.
Not all locks are created equal. The best mailboxes use 12-disc wafer locks that resist picking and drilling. Anti-pry latch mechanisms prevent the most common attack method - simply forcing the door open with a crowbar. Look for reinforced hinges and thick steel construction (14-gauge minimum, 12-gauge preferred). The Mail Boss models excel here with patented anti-pry technology that actually works.
Measure your typical weekly mail volume before buying. Standard models offer 300-500 cubic inches - fine for bills and letters. Medium capacity (1500-2000 cubic inches) handles magazines and small packages. Large capacity (2500+ cubic inches) suits online shoppers and home businesses. Remember, bigger isn't always better - oversized mailboxes can look out of place and require stronger mounting.
Wall-mounted mailboxes work great for homes with covered porches or secure entry areas. They're easier to install and check but typically offer less capacity. Curbside post-mounted options provide more capacity and meet USPS requirements for street delivery, but require proper post installation and mean walking to retrieve mail. Consider your physical capabilities and weather exposure when choosing.
Not all secure mailboxes meet USPS requirements. Approved models must allow carriers to deliver mail without a key while preventing retrieval without one. The Mail Boss line specifically addresses this with their baffle door systems. Check with your local post office if you're unsure about regulations in your area - some neighborhoods have specific requirements.
Rust kills more mailboxes than thieves steal. Galvanized steel with powder coating provides the best protection. Look for weather stripping around doors to keep contents dry. Drainage holes prevent water accumulation. The Architectural MailSafe's plastic/aluminum construction offers ultimate rust resistance for coastal areas.
Budget models ($25-50) offer basic security adequate for low-risk areas. Mid-range options ($75-150) provide serious security with quality construction - the sweet spot for most homeowners. Premium models ($150-300) add features like dual access, package capacity, or commercial-grade components. Consider the value of your typical mail and local theft rates when setting your budget.
Yes, especially if you live in an area with mail theft issues. A quality locking mailbox costs $75-150 but can prevent identity theft, check fraud, and package loss worth thousands. Even one prevented theft justifies the cost, plus you gain peace of mind when traveling or receiving valuable mail.
Absolutely. USPS-approved locking mailboxes use incoming mail slots or baffle doors that allow carriers to deposit mail without a key. The locking mechanism only prevents retrieval. Models like the Mail Boss series are specifically designed for standard mail delivery while maintaining security.
Wall-mounted models take 15-30 minutes with basic tools. Post-mounted curbside mailboxes require 1-2 hours including post installation. The hardest part is usually removing the old mailbox and ensuring proper height (41-45 inches) for USPS requirements. Most models include templates and hardware.
For average households, 1500-2000 cubic inches works perfectly. If you shop online frequently or run a home business, consider 2500+ cubic inches. Wall-mounted units typically offer 300-800 cubic inches - sufficient for apartments or light mail volume. Measure your weekly mail accumulation to decide.
Post-mounted mailboxes generally offer superior security due to heavier construction and more robust locking mechanisms. However, a quality wall-mounted box in a protected location (covered porch, secured entrance) can be equally secure. The Mail Boss post-mounted models provide the highest security level we tested.
Choose galvanized steel with powder coating for maximum rust resistance. Apply car wax annually to maintain the finish. Ensure drainage holes remain clear. For coastal areas, consider aluminum or plastic construction like the Architectural MailSafe. Regular maintenance extends lifespan significantly.
Determined thieves with power tools can breach any mailbox, but quality locking models make theft extremely difficult and time-consuming. Most mail theft is opportunistic - thieves want easy targets. A visible locking mailbox usually sends them looking elsewhere. Models with anti-pry latches and commercial-grade locks provide excellent deterrence.
Residential locks typically use 5-7 disc wafers and basic pins. Commercial-grade locks feature 12+ disc wafers, anti-drill plates, and hardened steel components. They resist picking and drilling far longer. The AdirOffice and Mail Boss models use commercial-grade locks worth the extra cost.
Many HOAs have specific mailbox requirements for aesthetics and uniformity. Check your CC&Rs before purchasing. Some associations require matching mailboxes but may allow locking inserts. The Architectural Mailboxes Designer series often meets HOA aesthetic requirements while providing security.
Most models include 2-3 keys. Premium brands like Mail Boss provide 3 keys standard. You can usually order replacements from manufacturers using your lock code. We recommend keeping one key inside your home, one on your keychain, and one in a secure backup location.
After six weeks of testing, installation headaches, and even some creative "break-in" attempts, we're confident in our recommendations. The Mail Boss 7506 emerges as the clear winner for most homeowners - it balances security, capacity, and price better than anything else we tested.
For those needing specific features, our category winners deliver exceptional value. The AdirOffice provides commercial-grade security at a residential price. The Mail Boss 7536 Street Safe solves the dangerous street retrieval problem brilliantly. Budget-conscious buyers can't go wrong with the KYODOLED at under $25.
If you're dealing with high package volume, invest in the Mail Boss Package Master despite its premium price - one prevented theft pays for it. Wall-mount fans should consider the xydled for maximum capacity or the Architectural Designer for style. The ultra-heavy-duty Mail Boss 7106 serves high-volume mail recipients perfectly.
Remember, the best locking mailbox is one you'll actually use consistently. Consider your mail volume, installation capabilities, and local crime rates when choosing. With mail theft rising 30% annually, protecting your mail isn't paranoia - it's smart home security that pays for itself.