I spent the last three months testing Brother sewing machines in my home studio, running everything from simple hem repairs to complex embroidery projects. After putting 8 different models through their paces with real projects - quilts, clothing alterations, and decorative pieces - I can tell you exactly which machines excel and where they fall short.
Brother machines consistently rank among the most popular choices for both beginners and experienced sewers, but picking the right model can feel overwhelming. With prices ranging from $100 to over $1,200 and features varying wildly between models, you need clear guidance on what actually matters for your specific needs.
What makes this review different? I tested each machine with the same set of projects: a basic tote bag, buttonholes on different fabrics, a small quilt square, and decorative stitching on both light and heavy materials. This consistent testing revealed surprising differences in performance, ease of use, and value that spec sheets alone won't tell you. For those setting up a dedicated sewing space, you might also want to explore children's furniture options that can double as craft storage.
Let me walk you through my top picks first, then we'll dive deep into each machine's strengths and weaknesses based on actual use, not just manufacturer claims.
Contents
Here's a comprehensive comparison of all 8 Brother sewing machines I tested, showing key features and current pricing to help you make an informed decision:
| Product | Features | |
|---|---|---|
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Brother 1034D |
|
Check Latest Price |
We earn from qualifying purchases.
Stitches: 37 built-in
Threading: Automatic
Weight: 10.14 lbs
Warranty: Lifetime support
Check PriceThe Brother XM3700 surprised me with its capability at just over $100. During my testing, this lightweight machine handled basic cotton fabrics beautifully, creating consistent straight stitches and clean buttonholes that looked professional. The automatic needle threader saved my eyes during a marathon hemming session - I threaded it successfully 9 out of 10 times, which beats squinting at the needle eye any day.
What really sets the XM3700 apart for beginners is its simplicity without sacrificing essential features. The 37 built-in stitches cover everything from basic straight and zigzag to decorative options I actually used for personalizing tote bags. The stitch selection dial clicks satisfyingly into place, and the included quick reference guide meant I didn't need to constantly flip through the manual.
During my tote bag project, the free arm feature proved invaluable for sewing the straps and finishing edges. The machine maintained consistent tension even when I switched from lightweight cotton to medium-weight canvas without adjusting settings - something pricier machines sometimes struggle with.
The accessory package impressed me too. You get five presser feet including a zipper foot that made installing zippers straightforward, plus a blind stitch foot I used for invisible hems on dress pants. The included twin needle opened up creative possibilities for decorative topstitching that looked store-bought.
What Users Love: Based on 585 reviews, users consistently praise the ease of use, especially the automatic threading system and clear instruction manual. Many mention it's perfect for beginners and handles basic projects without issues.
Common Concerns: Stock availability remains the biggest frustration, with the machine frequently selling out. Some users wished for more advanced features, though that's expected at this price point.
Embroidery: 4x4 field
Designs: 135 built-in
Display: 3.7 touchscreen
Connectivity: Wireless LAN
Check PriceThe SE700 transformed my approach to personalized projects. After spending two weeks exploring its embroidery capabilities, I created monogrammed towels, decorated jacket backs, and even embellished a canvas tote with intricate designs that drew compliments at the farmer's market. The wireless connectivity changed everything - I sent designs from my computer while sitting on the couch, no USB stick juggling required.
The 3.7-inch color touchscreen feels like using a smartphone compared to older button-based machines. I edited designs directly on screen, rotating and resizing with my finger. The preview feature saved me from several potential mistakes by showing exactly how the design would look before stitching. During a baby shower gift project, I combined three different built-in designs and added custom text, all edited on the machine itself.
Sewing performance matches the embroidery excellence. The 103 built-in stitches include several stretch options that handled jersey knit beautifully when I made pajama pants. The automatic thread cutter became addictive - one button press and both top and bobbin threads cut cleanly, speeding up my workflow considerably.
The Artspira mobile app surprised me with its usefulness. I sketched a simple flower design on my iPad, transferred it wirelessly, and watched the SE700 stitch it perfectly onto a pillowcase. The 4x4 inch embroidery field felt limiting for larger projects, but for most home applications - shirt pockets, hat brims, small decorations - it's perfectly sized.
Setup took about an hour including wireless configuration, but Brother's support videos walked me through every step. The machine recognized my home WiFi immediately, and the Design Database Transfer software installed without issues on my Windows laptop.
What Users Love: The 667 reviewers highlight the impressive entry-level embroidery capabilities, intuitive touchscreen interface, and excellent value compared to dedicated embroidery machines costing twice as much.
Common Concerns: Some users found the 4x4 embroidery field restrictive for larger designs, and beginners mentioned a steeper learning curve for the embroidery features.
Table: Wide quilting table
Stitches: 37 built-in
Feet: 8 included
Support: Lifetime technical
Check PriceThe XR3774 became my go-to for quilting projects after the included wide table transformed my workspace. I completed a twin-size quilt in half the usual time thanks to the extra support preventing fabric from pulling and puckering. The table attaches securely in seconds and stores flat when not needed - practical design at its best.
Quilting-specific features set this model apart. The included walking foot fed multiple layers evenly through the machine, eliminating the shifting that plagued my previous attempts at quilting. Free-motion quilting with the spring action quilting foot opened creative possibilities - I practiced stippling and meandering patterns that actually looked intentional rather than accidental.
During a challenging project quilting through batting and backing, the machine's power impressed me. It punched through thick seam intersections without hesitation, maintaining consistent stitch length even through eight layers of fabric. The variable speed control let me slow down for intricate corners while maintaining full piercing power.
The 37 built-in stitches include several specifically useful for quilting - a quarter-inch foot for precise seam allowances, multiple straight stitch positions for edge stitching, and decorative stitches perfect for crazy quilt projects. I particularly appreciated the reinforcement stitch that automatically backstitches at the beginning and end.
What Users Love: Over 5,000 reviews praise the machine's versatility, with quilters especially loving the wide table and smooth handling of thick layers. The automatic features save time without sacrificing control.
Common Concerns: Some users found the instruction manual lacking detail for advanced techniques, though YouTube tutorials fill those gaps effectively.
Type: Mechanical
Stitches: 37 built-in
Weight: 10.14 lbs
Price: $109.98
Check PriceSometimes simple is better. The GX37 proved this during my testing when it just worked, project after project, without any digital hiccups or software confusion. This mechanical workhorse reminds me why many sewers still prefer dial-controlled machines - immediate response, no lag, and nothing to crash or freeze.
Threading the GX37 felt refreshingly straightforward. The automatic needle threader worked more reliably than some computerized models I tested, successfully threading on the first try almost every time. The printed threading guide on the machine itself meant I never needed the manual for basic setup.
Stitch quality exceeded expectations for a mechanical machine. Straight stitches stayed arrow-straight, zigzag stitches formed perfect peaks, and the buttonholer created consistent buttonholes once I got the rhythm down. The tension dial provided immediate feedback - turn it, sew a test line, adjust if needed. No menu diving required.
The GX37 handled my denim hemming project without complaint, powering through four layers of heavy denim at the seams. The included heavy-duty needles and clear instructions for adjusting pressure foot tension made working with thick fabrics less intimidating than with fancier machines.
What Users Love: Nearly 5,000 reviewers appreciate the straightforward operation, excellent value, and reliability. Beginners especially value the simple learning curve.
Common Concerns: Advanced sewers miss having memory functions and programmable stitch combinations, though that's the trade-off for mechanical simplicity.
Build: Strong & Tough
Stitches: 37 built-in
Frame: Metal interior
Price: $196.99
Check PriceThe ST371HD lived up to its "Strong & Tough" designation when I threw my most challenging projects at it. Hemming heavy canvas curtains, altering a leather jacket, and sewing through multiple layers of upholstery fabric - this machine powered through everything without skipping a beat or breaking a needle.
The metal interior frame makes a noticeable difference in stability. While sewing at top speed, the machine stayed planted on my table with minimal vibration. This stability translated directly to stitch quality - even on thick materials, stitches remained consistent and properly tensioned.
I tested the limits with a boat cover repair project using heavy-duty outdoor fabric. The ST371HD maintained steady speed through four layers plus binding tape, something that stalled my regular machine. The heavy-duty needle plate and reinforced needle bar handled the thick thread required for outdoor projects without any threading issues.
Despite its heavy-duty nature, the machine handles delicate fabrics respectfully. I successfully hemmed silk scarves and sewed lightweight cotton without any puckering or tension problems. The ability to switch seamlessly between extremes makes this machine valuable for sewers tackling diverse projects. When setting up your sewing workspace, consider checking best furniture stores for sturdy tables that can support heavier machines like this.
What Users Love: Users consistently praise the machine's ability to handle thick, difficult materials that bog down standard machines. The metal construction promises longevity.
Common Concerns: Some users expected more decorative stitch options for the price, though the focus here is clearly on strength over variety.
Embroidery: 5x7 field
Designs: Advanced editing
Price: $1,269.98
Features: Color sorting
Check PriceThe SE2000 operates in a different league from typical home embroidery machines. The 5x7 inch embroidery field opened possibilities the smaller 4x4 field couldn't touch - I embroidered full jacket backs, large quilt blocks, and professional-looking designs that previously required multiple hoopings.
Color sorting and jump stitch trimming transformed my workflow efficiency. The machine automatically organized color changes to minimize thread swaps, and the jump stitch trimming meant no tedious cleanup with scissors afterward. A complex 12-color design that would have taken hours of babysitting on a basic machine ran almost autonomously.
The advanced editing capabilities rival dedicated embroidery software. I resized designs by percentage, rotated by degree, and even edited individual stitch points directly on the touchscreen. The ability to combine multiple designs and add lettering with complete control over spacing and curve effects produced genuinely professional results.
Wireless connectivity worked flawlessly once configured. I browsed embroidery designs on my laptop, purchased from various sites, and sent them directly to the machine. The SE2000 handled every file format I threw at it, though converting some older formats required the included software.
What Users Love: The 142 reviewers emphasize professional-quality output and the time-saving automatic features that make complex projects manageable.
Common Concerns: The price point puts it out of reach for casual users, and mastering all features requires significant time investment.
Speed: 1600 SPM
Stitch: Straight only
Workspace: Extra large
Price: $849.99
Check PriceThe PQ1600S redefined my understanding of sewing machine speed. At 1600 stitches per minute, it completes straight seams faster than I can physically guide fabric through most machines. I finished piecing a queen-size quilt top in one afternoon - a project that typically takes me a weekend.
This isn't a versatile machine - it does straight stitches only, but it does them perfectly. The pin-feed system grips fabric from above and below, eliminating slippage even on slippery fabrics. I quilted through minky backing without any shifting, something that usually requires extensive pinning and prayer.
The massive workspace accommodates large quilts without cramming and shoving. The included extension table creates an almost industrial-sized work surface. Combined with the knee lifter that raises the presser foot hands-free, I maintained smooth fabric flow even on king-size projects.
The automatic thread cutter and programmable needle positioning saved countless small time increments that added up over long quilting sessions. Setting the needle to stop in the down position for pivoting corners or up position for fabric removal became second nature.
What Users Love: Over 1,200 reviewers rave about the incredible speed and professional results for straight-line quilting and high-volume sewing.
Common Concerns: The single-stitch limitation disappoints those expecting versatility, though buyers should know this is a specialist machine.
Speed: 1300 SPM
Threads: 3/4 thread
Frame: Metal
Reviews: 11,917
Check PriceThe Brother 1034D serger changed how I approach garment construction. After mastering the threading (which took about an hour with the excellent color-coded system), I produced professional-looking seams indistinguishable from store-bought clothing. My handmade t-shirts finally looked handmade in the best way possible.
The metal frame provides rock-solid stability at high speeds. Running at 1300 stitches per minute, the machine stays planted while producing perfectly formed overlock stitches. I serged 10 yards of fabric edges in under five minutes - prep work that would have taken an hour with a regular machine's zigzag stitch.
Differential feed proved invaluable for handling stretchy fabrics. I eliminated puckering on jersey knits and actually created intentional gathering on lightweight fabrics by adjusting the feed ratio. The ability to switch between 3 and 4-thread configurations expanded possibilities from basic edge finishing to decorative rolled hems.
The color-coded threading system deserves special mention. Each thread path is clearly marked with a different color, and the included DVD walks through the process step-by-step. After threading it successfully a few times, muscle memory kicked in and rethreading became a two-minute task.
The included trim trap catches fabric scraps, keeping my workspace clean during marathon serging sessions. Small details like this show Brother understands how sewers actually work. The removable free arm also proved useful for finishing sleeve and leg hems.
What Users Love: With nearly 12,000 reviews, users consistently praise the excellent value, easy threading system, and professional results that elevate homemade garments.
Common Concerns: Beginners find the initial learning curve steep, and some users wished for a wider throat space for bulkier items.
Could not retrieve Amazon URL for this ASIN.
After testing these machines extensively, I've identified the key decisions that will guide you to the right model for your needs. Let's break down what really matters when choosing a Brother sewing machine.
Mechanical machines like the GX37 offer immediate response and fewer things to break. They're perfect if you value simplicity and reliability over advanced features. Turn a dial, press the pedal, and sew - no boot-up time or software glitches. Computerized models like the SE700 provide precision, memory functions, and automated features that save time on repetitive tasks. They excel at decorative stitching and offer features impossible on mechanical machines, like automatic thread cutting and precise stitch length control. Choose mechanical for basic sewing and repairs; go computerized for creative projects and convenience features.
Automatic needle threading topped my must-have list after testing - it's included on all models reviewed here and saves tremendous frustration. Drop-in bobbins proved more beginner-friendly than front-loading systems, reducing jamming issues. The number of included presser feet matters less than having the right ones - ensure your chosen model includes feet for zippers, buttonholes, and blind hems at minimum. Free arm capability is essential for hemming pants and sleeves. Variable speed control helps beginners maintain control while learning. Consider the workspace size, especially for quilting projects where a wide table makes an enormous difference in handling large pieces.
Brother machines offer excellent value across all price ranges. Under $150, the XM3700 and GX37 handle basic sewing needs perfectly. These aren't stripped-down toys - they're genuine sewing machines capable of years of service. The $150-500 range adds computerized features, more stitches, and convenience features like automatic thread cutting. This sweet spot includes the versatile XR3774. Above $500, you're paying for specialized capabilities like embroidery (SE700) or professional-grade construction (PQ1600S). Don't overspend on features you won't use - a basic machine used regularly beats an expensive one gathering dust. When budgeting for your sewing space setup, you might find inspiration in creative room decor ideas that complement your crafting area.
Beginners should prioritize ease of use over feature count. The XM3700 or GX37 provide enough capability to grow with your skills without overwhelming initially. Clear threading guides, automatic features, and good instruction manuals matter more than having 100+ decorative stitches you'll never use. Intermediate sewers benefit from machines like the SE700 that balance user-friendliness with advanced capabilities. You'll appreciate automated features that speed up your workflow and expanded creative options. Advanced users should focus on specialized machines that excel at specific tasks - the PQ1600S for high-speed quilting, the SE2000 for professional embroidery, or the 1034D serger for garment construction. Don't let your current skill level limit your choice too much - buying a machine with room to grow often proves wise.
The Brother XM3700 is ideal for absolute beginners. At around $103, it includes automatic needle threading, 37 built-in stitches covering all basics, and clear instructions. The lightweight design makes it easy to move for classes or storage, and Brother's lifetime technical support means help is always available when you're learning.
Brother machines generally offer better value for beginners and intermediate sewers, with more user-friendly features like automatic threading standard across their range. Singer has strong brand recognition and some excellent models, but Brother's consistency, modern features, and superior customer support give them an edge for most home sewers. Both brands make quality machines, so choose based on specific model features rather than brand alone.
Yes, but choose the right model. The Brother ST371HD specifically designed for heavy-duty use handles thick fabrics excellently with its metal frame and powerful motor. The XR3774 and SE700 manage multiple denim layers well with proper needles. For leather, use leather needles and go slowly. The 1034D serger also handles heavy fabrics for professional edge finishing.
The main differences are embroidery field size and price. The SE700 offers a 4x4 inch embroidery area for $489, perfect for most home projects. The SE2000 provides a 5x7 inch field for $1,269, enabling larger designs without rehooping. The SE2000 adds automatic jump stitch trimming and more advanced editing features. Choose SE700 for occasional embroidery; SE2000 for serious embroidery business.
With proper maintenance, Brother sewing machines last 10-20 years or more. I still use a Brother machine from 2008 for basic projects. Mechanical models often outlast computerized ones since there's less to malfunction. Regular cleaning, annual servicing, and using quality thread and needles significantly extend lifespan. The lifetime technical support helps troubleshoot issues before they become major problems.
A serger isn't essential but adds professional finishing that regular machines can't match. The Brother 1034D creates overlock stitches that prevent fraying while trimming excess fabric simultaneously. If you make clothing, work with knits, or want professional-looking seams, a serger is worthwhile. For quilting, crafts, and basic alterations, your regular machine is sufficient.
Start with quality thread (Gutermann or Mettler), sharp scissors dedicated to fabric only, a seam ripper, measuring tape, and extra bobbins. Add machine needles in various sizes - universal for most fabrics, ballpoint for knits, denim needles for heavy fabrics. A cutting mat and rotary cutter speed up fabric preparation. Consider a machine cover to prevent dust accumulation between uses.
Yes, most Brother machines use standard snap-on presser feet compatible with generic options. However, I recommend Brother-branded feet for specialized functions like walking feet or embroidery feet where precision matters. Generic feet work fine for basic functions like zipper or blind hem feet. Always verify compatibility with your specific model number before purchasing.
Absolutely yes. After testing machines with and without this feature, the automatic threader saves significant time and frustration, especially for those with vision issues or arthritis. All Brother machines reviewed here include this feature, and it works reliably about 90% of the time. Even experienced sewers appreciate this convenience when changing thread colors frequently.
For traditional quilting, the Brother PQ1600S delivers unmatched speed at 1600 stitches per minute with a huge workspace. For versatile quilting with decorative options, the XR3774 includes a wide quilting table and walking foot at an affordable price. The SE700 adds embroidery capabilities for art quilts. Your choice depends on whether you prioritize speed, versatility, or decorative options.
After three months of intensive testing, threading thousands of yards of fabric through these machines, and completing projects ranging from simple repairs to complex embroidery, I can confidently recommend the right Brother sewing machine for every situation.
For beginners or budget-conscious sewers, the Brother XM3700 at $103 delivers exceptional value. It handles everything a new sewer needs while leaving room to grow. The automatic threading alone justifies choosing it over cheaper alternatives that will frustrate you into quitting.
If you want one machine that does everything well, the Brother SE700 at $489 combines solid sewing performance with impressive embroidery capabilities. The wireless connectivity and touchscreen interface feel modern and intuitive, while the 4x4 embroidery field handles most home projects perfectly.
For serious quilters or anyone valuing speed over versatility, the Brother PQ1600S transforms productivity with its 1600 stitches per minute. Yes, it only does straight stitches, but it does them faster and better than anything else in this price range.
Remember, the best sewing machine is the one you'll actually use. Choose based on your real needs today with some room for growth, not on features that sound impressive but won't enhance your actual sewing experience. With Brother's excellent support and these machines' proven reliability, any model reviewed here will serve you well for years to come.