RosenBerryRooms is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

Fisch FischFright Appraisal Event Ultimate Guide (October 2025)

By: Osama
Updated On: October 20, 2025

The Fisch FischFright 2025 event runs from October 18 to November 1, bringing exclusive mutations, 28 new fish, and limited-time rewards to Roblox players. This complete guide covers appraisal mechanics, mutation strategies, and quest walkthroughs to help you maximize your Halloween fishing experience before the event ends.

Fisch FischFright

Quick Reference: FischFright 2025 Event Overview

Event DetailInformation
DurationOctober 18, 2025 - November 1, 2025
LocationCrook's Hallow (new event area)
Total Fish28 exclusive event fish
Mutations6 exclusive mutations
Main CurrencyCandy (from Trick-or-Treating)
Key NPCsAppraiser, Beatrix the Witch, Flying Dutchman

Getting to Crook's Hallow: Your Event Hub

Crook's Hallow serves as the central location for the FischFright 2025 event. You have two primary methods to reach this spooky new area:

Contents

Method 1: Flying Dutchman Transport

Head to the south side of Moosewood Island where you'll find the Flying Dutchman standing on his ship. Interact with him and select "Take me to Crook's Hallow!" to be instantly teleported to the event area.

Method 2: Frightful Mirror

When you log in during the event period, you'll automatically receive a Frightful Mirror. Use this item to teleport directly to Crook's Hallow at any time.

Navigation in Crook's Hallow

Once you arrive, you'll find yourself in a Halloween-themed fishing village with:

  • Multiple haunted houses for Trick-or-Treating
  • The Witch's cauldron area (GPS: 32.9, 137.2, -11,562.4)
  • Ocean fishing spots surrounding the island
  • Various NPCs with quests and services

Understanding the Appraisal System

The FischFright Appraisal system is your primary method for obtaining exclusive Halloween mutations. This specialized appraisal works differently from regular Fisch appraisals and is essential for completing your event bestiary.

Locating the FischFright Appraiser

The Appraiser NPC is located in Crook's Hallow at coordinates 43, 141, -11623. You'll find them:

  • In the purple house to the left of Beatrix the Witch
  • Beside the merchant NPC
  • Behind the Witch's cauldron setup

How Appraisal Works?

  1. Approach the Appraiser and select "Can you appraise this fish?"
  2. Pay the appraisal fee (varies based on fish weight and rarity)
  3. Receive your appraised fish with potential mutations

Pro Tip: If you own the Appraiser's Luck game pass, your appraisal costs will be significantly reduced, making it more economical to appraise multiple fish.

Identifying Appraised Fish

Successfully appraised fish and items will display a small green dot in the bottom-left corner of their icon. This visual indicator helps you track which fish have undergone the appraisal process.

Exclusive Halloween Mutations Guide

The FischFright 2025 event introduces 6 exclusive mutations that can transform ordinary fish into valuable Halloween-themed catches. These mutations are crucial for completing quests and obtaining the best event rewards.

Complete Mutation Overview

MutationAcquisition MethodEffectCandy Cost
FrightfulFrightful Relic10% chance to apply mutation2,000 Candy
SpookySpooky Relic or Spooky RodApplies spooky mutation2,500 Candy
HauntedAppraisal only (Haunted Rod discontinued)Adds haunted effectN/A
EerieEerie Relic (secondary enchantment)Can stack with other mutations2,500 Candy
NightmareEvent drops and appraisalRare nightmare mutationN/A
WickedSpecial event methodsHigh-value wicked mutationN/A
Jack's CurseLimited-time event rewardUltimate Halloween mutationN/A

Detailed Mutation Strategies

Frightful Mutation

The Frightful mutation is one of the most accessible and valuable Halloween mutations:

  • Acquisition: Purchase the Frightful Relic from the Flying Dutchman for 2,000 Candy
  • Alternative: 0.49% drop chance from Trick-or-Treating
  • Usage: Enchant your rod with the Frightful Relic for a consistent 10% mutation chance
  • Strategy: This is ideal for early-game players due to its reliable proc rate and reasonable cost

Eerie Mutation

The Eerie mutation offers unique stacking capabilities:

  • Acquisition: Flying Dutchman for 2,500 Candy or 0.49% Trick-or-Treat chance
  • Special Feature: Works as a secondary enchantment
  • Pro Strategy: Stack Frightful + Eerie relics on one rod for significantly increased mutation frequency
  • Benefit: Essential for completing Halloween questlines efficiently

Spooky Mutation

Multiple acquisition methods make this mutation versatile:

  • Primary Method: Purchase Spooky Relic (2,500 Candy)
  • Alternative Methods:
    • Use the Spooky Rod directly
    • 0.49% chance from Trick-or-Treating
  • Quest Importance: Required for several NPC quests and the Pumpkin King's spotlight challenges

Haunted Mutation

Since the Haunted Rod is discontinued, appraisal is your only option:

  • Method: Use the FischFright Appraiser in Crook's Hallow
  • Strategy: Focus appraisal efforts on high-value fish to maximize returns
  • Note: This mutation is particularly rare and valuable for completionists

Complete Fish Bestiary: All 28 Event Fish

The FischFright 2025 event features 28 exclusive fish, each with unique preferences, conditions, and values. This comprehensive table will help you target specific fish for your collection and quests.

Fish Acquisition Guide

Fish NameAcquisition MethodPreferred TimePreferred WeatherPreferred BaitAvg. Value (C$)
Baby NessieTrick-or-TreatingNightAnyGobstopper7,187.5
Candle CarpFrightful Village/Nessie's CatacombNightWindySour Gummy Worm257.1
Candy Corn CodTrick-or-TreatingDayAnyHallow-Pop240
Caramel ChubTrick-or-Treating/Frightful CratesNightClearGummy Fish166.7
Coffin CrabFrightful Village/Nessie's CatacombDayRainyGummy Fish333.3
Ectoplasm EelFrightful Village/Nessie's CatacombAnyWindyHallow-Pop666.7
Eerie RelicTrick-or-Treat/Flying DutchmanAnyAnyHallow-Pop1,000
FrankenshrimpFrightful VillageDayFoggyCandy CornN/A
Frightful CrateFrightful VillageAnyAnyMagnet800
Frightful RelicTrick-or-Treat/Flying DutchmanNightFoggyCandy Corn1,000
Ghost MinnowFrightful Village/Nessie's CatacombDayRainyGobstopper87.5
Gravestone StingrayFrightful Village/Nessie's CatacombAnyFoggySour Gummy Worm5,600
Gummy GuppyTrick-or-Treating/Frightful CratesDayWindyHallow-Pop133.3
Jack-o-LanternAnywhereAnyClearGummy Fish1,280
KelpieFrightful PoolsAnyRainyGummy Fish8,333
Licorice LeechTrick-or-Treating/Frightful CratesAnyRainyGobstopper150
Lollipop LampreyTrick-or-Treating/Frightful CratesAnyClearCandy Corn187.5
Marshmallow MackerelTrick-or-Treating/Frightful CratesNightRainyGummy Fish250
Mourning Manta RayFrightful Village/Nessie's CatacombAnyWindySour Gummy Worm10,650
Phantom JellyfishFrightful PoolsNightWindyHallow-Pop533.3
Potion PerchFrightful Village/Nessie's CatacombDayAnyGobstopper466.7
Pumpkin PufferfishFrightful Village/Nessie's CatacombNightAnyHallow-Pop125
ScarecrowAnywhereDayFoggySour Gummy Worm400
Skeletal NessieNessie's CatacombAnyRainyGummy Fish10,000
Spider SalmonFrightful PoolsAnyAnyGobstopper1,237.5
Spooky RelicTrick-or-Treat/Flying DutchmanDayClearGummy Fish1,000
Vampire PerchFrightful PoolsDayClearCandy Corn800
Werewolf WalleyeFrightful PoolsNightFoggySour Gummy Worm1,466.7
Xtra Sour Gummy PackFrightful CrateAnyAnyMagnet100

High-Value Target Fish

Focus on these fish for maximum returns and quest completion:

  1. Skeletal Nessie (10,000 C$) - Highest value fish, found in Nessie's Catacomb
  2. Mourning Manta Ray (10,650 C$) - Second highest, requires windy weather
  3. Kelpie (8,333 C$) - Found in Frightful Pools, rainy weather preferred
  4. Baby Nessie (7,187.5 C$) - Trick-or-Treat exclusive, night time preferred

Frightful Pools: Exclusive Fishing Locations

Frightful Pools are special fishing areas that spawn randomly and offer unique fish not found elsewhere. Understanding these pools is crucial for completing your event bestiary.

Five Types of Frightful Pools

Pool TypeLocationExclusive FishSpecial Features
Blue Frightful PoolOcean spawnsPhantom JellyfishEnhanced night fishing
Green Frightful PoolOcean spawnsSpider SalmonBalanced catch rates
Orange Frightful PoolOcean spawnsVampire PerchDay fishing bonus
Purple Frightful PoolOcean spawnsWerewolf WalleyeNight/foggy weather bonus
Red Frightful PoolOcean spawnsKelpieRainy weather bonus

Frightful Pool Mechanics

  • Spawn Rate: Pools appear every hour in the ocean
  • Duration: Pools despawn after a limited time
  • Accessibility: You don't need to be in Crook's Hallow to access these pools
  • Visual Indicators: Each pool type has distinct visual effects and colors

Pro Tip: The Frightful Pools are also the primary source for colored Frightful Skulls, which are essential for certain quests and the Pumpkin King's challenges.

Trick-or-Treating System: Candy Collection Guide

Candy is the primary currency for the FischFright event, and Trick-or-Treating is your main method for acquiring it. Master this system to purchase exclusive items and complete quests efficiently.

Getting Started with Trick-or-Treating

  1. Automatic Equipment: You'll receive a Candy Bucket automatically when you log in during the event
  2. Location: Head to Crook's Hallow and look for houses with closed doors
  3. Interaction: Stand next to a door with your Candy Bucket equipped
  4. Timing: Each house can be trick-or-treated every 10 minutes

Candy Rewards and Drop Rates

Reward TypeDrop ChanceValue
Candy (Common)70%10-50 Candy
Rare Fish20%Various event fish
Relics0.49%Frightful/Spooky/Eerie Relics
Exclusive Items9.51%Masks, lanterns, special bait

Optimal Trick-or-Treating Strategy

  1. House Rotation: Create a route covering all houses in Crook's Hallow
  2. Timing: Set a timer for the 10-minute cooldown between visits
  3. Group Activities: Coordinate with friends to cover more houses efficiently
  4. Priority Targets: Focus on houses near the Witch's cauldron for slightly better drop rates

Complete NPC Quest Guide

The FischFright event features numerous NPCs with unique quests that reward Candy and essential items. Completing these quests is vital for progression and obtaining the best event rewards.

All NPCs and Their Quests

NPC NameLocation (GPS)Quest RequirementReward
Beatrix the Fisch Witch32.9, 137.2, -11,562.4Find ingredients for cauldronWitch's blessings
Edris179.8, 143.8, -11,752.2Catch a Scarecrow750 Candy
Elara204.4, 144.7, -11,540.9Catch a Sparkling Candy Corn Cod350 Candy
Evil Clown428.1, 210.8, -11,635.6Catch a Shiny Mourning Manta Ray750 Candy
Ghost412.1, 213.8, -11,627.6Catch a Sparkling Ghost Minnow440 Candy
Headless Horseman-1.1, 147.7, -11,461.8Multiple Jack-o-Blazer questsJack-o-Blazer Rod progression
Jack Skellington395.9, 213.8, -11,606.8Catch a Coffin Crab200 Candy
Jasper239.9, 162.7, -11,572.1Catch a Shiny Werewolf Walleye400 Candy
Jeremy395.9, 213.8, -11,606.8Catch a Xtra Sour Gummy Pack150 Candy
Lilith134.8, 145.9, -11,500.9Catch a Baby Nessie1,000 Candy
Patchen0.8, 150.8, -11,346.9Catch a Shiny Candle Carp400 Candy
Pete189.6, 144.5, -11,423.2Catch a Shiny Gummy Guppy400 Candy
Pumpkin King202, 143.8, -11,778Harvest pumpkins, catch spooky fishRoblox Halloween Tokens

Headless Horseman Jack-o-Blazer Quest Series

This is the most important quest chain for obtaining the best event rod:

Jack-o-Blazer I: Catch a Frightful Jack-o-Lantern

Jack-o-Blazer II: Collect 5 Wisps

Jack-o-Blazer III: Obtain a Haunted Candle

Jack-o-Blazer IV: Find a Blazed Handle

Jack-o-Blazer V: Pay 5,000 Candy

Reward: Jack-o-Blazer Rod (one of the best event fishing rods)

Pumpkin King Spotlight Challenges

The Pumpkin King offers special quests that are part of the broader Roblox 2025 Halloween event:

Spotlight 1: Harvest, carve, and give away pumpkins

Spotlight 2: Catch spooky mutated fish and obtain the Spooky Rod from the Witch

Rewards: Standard and Elite Roblox Halloween Tokens

Flying Dutchman: Exclusive Event Shop

The Flying Dutchman NPC spawns every 10 minutes in Crook's Hallow with his ship, offering limited-time items for Candy. This is your primary source for event-exclusive rods, relics, and cosmetic items.

Flying Dutchman Spawn Mechanics

  • Spawn Interval: Every 10 minutes
  • Duration: Stays for a limited time before despawning
  • Notification: Location announcement appears on screen when he spawns
  • Items: Sells 3 random items from the available pool each spawn

Complete Item Catalog

ItemTypeCandy CostDescription
Bat Whisperer RodFishing Rod10,000High-tier event rod with bat-themed bonuses
Dusekkar RodFishing Rod25,000Premium event rod with enhanced mutation chances
Frightful RelicRelic2,000Applies Frightful mutation to rods
Spooky RelicRelic2,000Applies Spooky mutation to rods
Eerie RelicRelic2,500Secondary enchantment for stacking mutations
Scylla MaskCosmetic1,500Halloween mask cosmetic item
Megalodon MaskCosmetic1,500Shark-themed Halloween mask
Frightful Pool TotemUtility3,000Summons Frightful Pools on demand

Shopping Strategy

  1. Priority Purchases: Focus on relics first for mutation capabilities
  2. Rod Investment: The Bat Whisperer Rod offers the best value for most players
  3. Cosmetic Consideration: Masks are purely cosmetic but show event participation
  4. Budget Management: Save at least 5,000 Candy for the Jack-o-Blazer Rod quest

Witch's Ingredients Collection System

Witch's Ingredients are essential crafting materials for the FischFright event. These ingredients are used by Beatrix the Fisch Witch and are required for various quests and crafting recipes.

Obtaining Witch's Ingredients

Spawn Mechanics:

  • Spawn Rate: One Goblin spawns every 5 minutes
  • Multiple Spawns: It's possible for multiple Goblins to exist simultaneously
  • Location: Goblins spawn randomly around the map
  • Interaction: Find and complete their quests to receive one Witch's Ingredient

Important Notes:

  • Ingredients cannot be traded between players
  • Each Goblin offers a unique mini-quest
  • Quest difficulty varies but typically involves catching specific fish

Common Goblin Quest Types

  1. Fish Collection: Catch specific Halloween fish
  2. Candy Delivery: Bring a certain amount of Candy
  3. Trick-or-Treat: Visit specific houses in Crook's Hallow
  4. Pumpkin Harvest: Collect and carve pumpkins
  5. Ghost Hunting: Find and interact with ghost NPCs

Pro Tip: Keep a stock of common event fish in your inventory to quickly complete Goblin quests when they appear.

Advanced Fishing Strategies for Maximum Efficiency

To maximize your success during the FischFright event, you need advanced strategies that go beyond basic fishing techniques. These methods will help you catch rare fish, complete quests faster, and earn more Candy.

Optimal Fishing Setup

Recommended Rod Configuration:

  • Primary Rod: Bat Whisperer Rod (10,000 Candy from Flying Dutchman)
  • Enchantments: Frightful + Eerie relic stack
  • Bait: Hallow-Pop for most fish, Sour Gummy Worm for high-value targets
  • Location: Frightful Pools during preferred weather conditions

Weather and Time Optimization:

  • Foggy Weather: Best for Gravestone Stingray, Werewolf Walleye, and Scarecrow
  • Windy Weather: Ideal for Phantom Jellyfish, Mourning Manta Ray, and Candle Carp
  • Rainy Weather: Perfect for Kelpie, Skeletal Nessie, and Coffin Crab
  • Night Fishing: Higher spawn rates for Baby Nessie, Pumpkin Pufferfish, and Werewolf Walleye

Mutation Stacking Strategy

The most advanced technique in FischFright is mutation stacking:

Step 1: Acquire both Frightful Relic (2,000 Candy) and Eerie Relic (2,500 Candy)

Step 2: Enchant your primary rod with Frightful mutation first

Step 3: Add Eerie relic as a secondary enchantment

Step 4: Fish in Frightful Pools during optimal weather conditions

Expected Results:

  • Base Mutation Chance: 10% (Frightful)
  • Stacked Bonus: Additional 5-8% from Eerie
  • Total Mutation Rate: 15-18% per cast
  • Efficiency: Nearly doubles your mutation acquisition rate

Economy Management

Candy Budget Planning:

  • Essential Purchases (7,500 Candy): Frightful + Eerie relics
  • Rod Investment (10,000 Candy): Bat Whisperer Rod
  • Quest Completion (5,000 Candy): Jack-o-Blazer final payment
  • Total Minimum: 22,500 Candy per player

Candy Acquisition Rate:

  • Trick-or-Treating: 200-500 Candy per hour
  • Quest Completion: 100-1,000 Candy per quest
  • Fish Sales: 50-200 Candy per valuable fish
  • Daily Target: Aim for 1,000+ Candy per active playing session

Event Rewards and Completion Guide

Completing the FischFright 2025 event rewards you with exclusive items, titles, and bragging rights. This section details all available rewards and how to unlock them.

Complete Reward Catalog

Exclusive Titles (9 Available):

  • Frightful, Spooky, 🧟, 👻, 🧛‍♂️, 🎃, 🍬, 💀, Eerie

Bobbers (4 Available):

  • Eyeball Bobber, Gravestone Bobber, Ghost Bobber, Spider Bobber

Lanterns (2 Available):

  • Coffin Lantern, Wisp Flame Lantern

Relics (3 Available):

  • Frightful Relic, Spooky Relic, Eerie Relic

Boats (1 Available):

  • Dutchman's Spirit

Fishing Rods (5 Available):

  • Bat Whisperer Rod, Dusekkar Rod, Jack-o-Blazer Rod, Necrotic Rod, Spooky Rod

Completion Requirements

100% Bestiary Completion:

  • Catch all 28 event fish
  • Obtain at least one of each mutation type
  • Complete all NPC quests
  • Purchase all exclusive items from Flying Dutchman

Estimated Time Investment:

  • Casual Player: 20-30 hours for 100% completion
  • Dedicated Player: 10-15 hours for 100% completion
  • Speed Runner: 6-8 hours with optimal strategies

Community Resources and Official Links

Stay connected with the Fisch community and get the latest event updates through these official and community resources.

Official Resources

  • Official Fisch Discord: Join for real-time event updates, community discussions, and developer announcements
  • Fischipedia Wiki: The official knowledge base for all Fisch game information and event details
  • Roblox Fisch Group: Official Roblox group for game news and updates

Community Resources

  • Fisch Subreddit: Active community for tips, tricks, and player experiences
  • Fisch YouTube Community: Video guides, event coverage, and strategy tutorials
  • Fisch Twitter/X: Official announcements and event notifications

Why Join These Communities?

  • Real-time Updates: Get instant notifications about event changes and new content
  • Player Tips: Learn strategies from experienced players
  • Trading Opportunities: Connect with other players for item exchanges
  • Event Coordination: Team up with others for difficult quests and challenges

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Where is the FischFright Appraiser located?

A: The FischFright Appraiser is located in Crook's Hallow at coordinates 43, 141, -11623. You'll find the NPC in the purple house to the left of Beatrix the Witch, beside the merchant.

Q: What is the drop chance for Trick-or-Treat relics?

A: All relics (Frightful, Spooky, Eerie) have a 0.49% drop rate from Trick-or-Treating. This means approximately 1 in 200 Trick-or-Treat attempts will yield a relic.

Q: Can I stack Frightful and Eerie relics?

A: Yes, you can stack these relics. The Eerie relic works as a secondary enchantment, allowing you to combine it with the Frightful relic for significantly increased mutation frequency.

Q: Is the Haunted Rod still obtainable?

A: No, the Haunted Rod is discontinued and no longer available. Your best option for obtaining Haunted mutations is through the FischFright Appraisal system in Crook's Hallow.

Q: How long does the FischFright 2025 event last?

A: The event runs from October 18, 2025, to November 1, 2025. You have approximately two weeks to complete all event content and obtain exclusive rewards.

Q: What's the best fishing rod for the FischFright event?

A: The Bat Whisperer Rod (10,000 Candy from Flying Dutchman) offers the best value for most players. The Jack-o-Blazer Rod is also excellent but requires completing the Headless Horseman quest series.

Q: How do I get to Crook's Hallow?

A: You can reach Crook's Hallow by either interacting with the Flying Dutchman on the south side of Moosewood Island or using the Frightful Mirror you receive automatically when logging in during the event.

Q: What are Frightful Pools and how do they work?

A: Frightful Pools are special fishing areas that spawn every hour in the ocean. There are five types (Blue, Green, Orange, Purple, Red), each offering exclusive fish and enhanced fishing conditions.

Q: How often can I Trick-or-Treat?

A: You can Trick-or-Treat at each house every 10 minutes. The game will show a popup when you can interact with a house, provided you have your Candy Bucket equipped.

Q: What's the most valuable fish in FischFright 2025?

A: The Mourning Manta Ray is the most valuable fish at 10,650 C$, followed by Skeletal Nessie at 10,000 C$. Both require specific conditions and are quite rare.

Final Tips for Event Success

As we approach the end of this comprehensive guide, here are some final tips to ensure your FischFright 2025 success:

Last-Minute Checklist

  • Complete all NPC quests before November 1st
  • Obtain all 6 exclusive mutations
  • Catch all 28 event fish for 100% bestiary completion
  • Purchase all exclusive items from the Flying Dutchman
  • Complete the Jack-o-Blazer quest series for the ultimate rod
  • Participate in the Pumpkin King's spotlight challenges

Time Management Strategy

With the event ending November 1st, prioritize:

  1. Week 1: Focus on Candy accumulation and basic mutations
  2. Week 2: Complete advanced quests and rare fish hunting
  3. Final Days: Finish bestiary completion and purchase remaining items

Remember to Have Fun!

While this guide provides comprehensive strategies for maximizing your FischFright experience, don't forget to enjoy the Halloween atmosphere, connect with the community, and celebrate the spooky season in Roblox style.

Happy fishing, and may your nets be full of Halloween treasures! 🎃👻🧛‍♂️

Bookmark this guide for quick reference during the event, and check back for updates as new information becomes available throughout the FischFright 2025 event!

Copyright © RosenBerryRooms.Com 2022. All Rights Reserved.
magnifiercross
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram