RosenBerryRooms is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.
How to Get Frightful Jack-O'-Lantern in Fisch (October 2025)
By: Osama
Updated On: October 19, 2025
The Frightful Jack-O'-Lantern in Fisch's Halloween event is obtained by fishing in any body of water during FischFright 2025, then either using a Frightful Relic on your rod for a 10% mutation chance or appraising a regular Jack-O'-Lantern at the FischFright Appraiser NPC. This essential item is required for the Headless Horseman quest and can only be caught between October 18 - November 1, 2025.
Quick Reference: Jack-O'-Lantern Essentials
Requirement
Details
Event Duration
October 18 - November 1, 2025
Rarity
Limited (Luck-favoring)
Best Weather
Clear
Season
Autumn
Preferred Bait
Gummy Fish
Required Mutation
Frightful
Quest Usage
Headless Horseman Quest 1
Base Value
1,600 C$ (35kg)
What is the Jack-O'-Lantern?
The Jack-O'-Lantern is a limited-time Halloween fish in Fisch that serves as a crucial quest item for the Headless Horseman storyline during the FischFright 2025 event. Unlike regular fish, this spooky item appears as a carved pumpkin that someone "threw into the ocean for you to catch," according to its bestiary entry.
Contents
Key Characteristics:
Limited Availability: Only obtainable during the FischFright event
Quest Critical: Required for the first Headless Horseman quest
Mutation Needed: Must be "Frightful" variant to complete the quest
Luck-Favoring: Higher luck stats increase your chances of catching it
Understanding the Frightful Mutation
The most confusing aspect for many players is understanding the "Frightful" requirement. The Headless Horseman specifically asks for a "Frightful Jack-O'-Lantern," which means you need either:
Method 1: Frightful Relic Enchantment
Cost: 2,000 Candy from the Flying Dutchman
Effect: 10% chance to apply Frightful mutation to any fish caught
How to Get: Purchase from Flying Dutchman when he appears in Crook's Hallow
Alternative: 0.49% chance from Trick-or-Treating
Method 2: Post-Catch Appraisal
Catch a regular Jack-O'-Lantern first
Visit the FischFright Appraiser NPC at Crook's Hallow
Select "Can you appraise this fish?"
Pay the appraisal fee (varies by fish weight and rarity)
Receive Frightful mutation (random chance)
Pro Tip: The appraisal method is often more reliable since you guarantee a Jack-O'-Lantern first, then focus on the mutation separately.
Optimal Fishing Strategy
Location Selection
While Jack-O'-Lanterns can be caught in any body of water during the event, certain locations yield better results:
Recommended Fishing Spots:
Crook's Hallow waters: Highest spawn rate due to event proximity
Near event NPCs: Increased limited fish activity
Areas with other players: Community fishing can trigger spawns
Rod and Equipment Setup
Best Rods for Jack-O'-Lantern Fishing:
Spooky Rod: Natural mutation chance for Halloween fish
Any rod with Frightful Relic: 10% Frightful mutation chance
High Luck rods: Increased chance for limited fish spawns
Essential Enchantments:
Mystical: +25% Luck, +45% Resilience
Lucky: +20% Luck, +40% mutation chance
Quality: Balanced stats for general fishing
Bait and Conditions
Optimal Setup:
Bait: Gummy Fish (Jack-O'-Lantern's preferred bait)
Season: Autumn (event only occurs during this season)
Step-by-Step Jack-O'-Lantern Acquisition
Phase 1: Preparation
Stock up on Gummy Fish bait (purchase from event merchants)
Acquire 2,000 Candy for Frightful Relic (optional but recommended)
Choose your fishing rod (high luck preferred)
Wait for Clear weather (check weather forecast in-game)
Phase 2: Fishing
Travel to Crook's Hallow (main event island)
Find a good fishing spot near water bodies
Apply Frightful Relic if you purchased it
Cast your line with Gummy Fish bait
Be patient - drop rates are very low for limited fish
Phase 3: Mutation (if not using Frightful Relic)
Catch any Jack-O'-Lantern (regular variant)
Locate the FischFright Appraiser NPC
Coordinates: 43, 141, -11623
Found behind the Witch, beside the merchant
Select appraisal option
Pay the fee (reduced with Luck Game Pass)
Receive your Frightful Jack-O'-Lantern
Headless Horseman Quest Integration
The Jack-O'-Lantern is the first step in the Jack-o-Blazer questline:
Complete Quest Progression:
Jack-o-Blazer I: Find a Frightful Jack-O'-Lantern ✅
Jack-o-Blazer II: Collect 5 Wisps from graveyard
Jack-o-Blazer III: Find a Haunted Candle in the Mansion
Jack-o-Blazer IV: Obtain a Blazed Handle from Witch's Cauldron
Jack-o-Blazer V: Collect 5,000 Candy
Reward: Jack-o-Blazer Rod (exclusive event item with Wicked and Jack's Curse mutations)
Advanced Tips and Strategies
Efficiency Maximization
Multi-task while fishing: Complete other event quests simultaneously
Join community fishing groups: More players can trigger spawns
Use the Spooky Rod: Natural mutation synergy with Halloween fish
Stack mutations: Combine Frightful + Eerie relics for better odds
Candy Farming for Frightful Relic
If you need 2,000 Candy for the Frightful Relic:
Trick-or-Treat: 5-20 Candy per house (10-minute cooldown)
Complete NPC quests: Various candy rewards
Submit ingredients to Witch: Random FischFright rewards
Open Frightful Crates: Chance for candy and other items
Weather Manipulation
Check weather forecast: Available in-game
Server hop: Find servers with Clear weather
Wait it out: Weather changes periodically in-game
Common Mistakes to Avoid
1. Ignoring Weather Conditions
Many players waste time fishing in non-optimal weather. Clear weather dramatically increases Jack-O'-Lantern spawn rates.
2. Wrong Bait Usage
Using generic bait instead of Gummy Fish significantly reduces your chances. Always use the preferred bait.
3. Mutation Confusion
Don't assume any Jack-O'-Lantern works. The quest specifically requires the Frightful variant.
4. Poor Location Choice
While you can fish anywhere, Crook's Hallow waters have the highest concentration of event fish.
5. Impatience
Limited fish have very low spawn rates. Be prepared for extended fishing sessions.
Community Resources
Official Channels
Discord Server: Join the official Fisch Discord for real-time tips and community events
Twitter/X: Follow @FischGame for official announcements and updates
YouTube Channel: Subscribe for developer tutorials and event guides
Community Resources
Fisch Wiki: Comprehensive database of all game mechanics and items
Fischipedia: Official wiki with detailed statistics and guides
Reddit Community: r/FischGame for player discussions and strategy sharing
TikTok Creators: Many players share quick tips and discovery videos
Frequently Asked Questions
How rare is the Jack-O'-Lantern?
The Jack-O'-Lantern is a Limited fish with very low spawn rates. While exact percentages aren't published, players report spending 1-3 hours of active fishing to catch one.
Can I catch Jack-O'-Lantern without the Frightful mutation?
Yes, you can catch a regular Jack-O'-Lantern, but you must have the Frightful mutation to complete the Headless Horseman quest.
What's the fastest way to get the Frightful mutation?
The Frightful Relic method (10% chance per catch) is generally faster than appraisal, but costs 2,000 Candy. Appraisal is more reliable if you already have a Jack-O'-Lantern.
Does the Jack-O'-Lantern spawn in all fishing areas?
Yes, Jack-O'-Lantern can be caught in any body of water during the FischFright event, but Crook's Hallow has the highest concentration.
What happens if the event ends before I get it?
The Jack-O'-Lantern and all FischFright items become unavailable after November 1, 2025. You must obtain it before the event concludes.
Can I trade Jack-O'-Lantern with other players?
Currently, trading is not available for limited event items like the Jack-O'-Lantern.
How much Candy do I need for the entire questline?
You need 5,000 Candy for the final Headless Horseman quest, plus 2,000 Candy if you want the Frightful Relic, totaling 7,000 Candy.
Conclusion
Getting the Frightful Jack-O'-Lantern in Fisch's Halloween event requires patience, strategy, and understanding of the game's mutation mechanics. By following this comprehensive guide, you'll maximize your chances of obtaining this essential quest item before the FischFright event ends on November 1, 2025.
Remember to fish in Clear weather with Gummy Fish bait, consider investing in the Frightful Relic for better mutation odds, and don't hesitate to use the appraisal system if you're struggling with the mutation process. The Jack-o-Blazer Rod reward is well worth the effort, offering unique mutations that will serve you well beyond the Halloween event.
Happy fishing, and may your Jack-O'-Lantern be properly Frightful!
Bookmark this guide and check back for updates as the event progresses. Join our Discord community for real-time tips and tricks from fellow Fisch players!
RosenberryRooms is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.