I spent three weeks testing different under-sink trash can systems after getting tired of that ugly bin taking up precious floor space in my kitchen. What started as a simple cabinet organization project turned into discovering just how much the right under-sink solution can transform your entire kitchen workflow.
After installing and testing 11 different models - from basic plastic bins to sophisticated pull-out systems with soft-close mechanisms - I found dramatic differences in quality, functionality, and actual cabinet compatibility. The best part? Once you find the right system, you'll wonder how you ever lived without that hidden, convenient waste management setup.
Contents
Whether you're dealing with tricky plumbing configurations, limited cabinet width, or need a dual-compartment system for recycling, I've tested solutions for every scenario. My testing revealed that while some popular models look great online, they often fail in real-world cabinet installations due to poor slide quality or incompatible dimensions.
| Product | Features | |
|---|---|---|
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
|
|
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
|
|
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
We earn from qualifying purchases.
Before you buy any under-sink trash can, grab a tape measure and spend five minutes mapping your cabinet space. I learned this lesson the hard way when my first "perfect" pull-out system arrived and couldn't clear the disposal pipes. Here's exactly what you need to measure and consider for a successful installation.
Start by measuring your cabinet opening width - not the outside, but the actual opening between the face frames. Most pull-out systems need at least 11 inches of clearance, though some require 14.5 inches minimum. Next, measure from the cabinet floor to any plumbing obstacles. Standard P-traps sit about 10-15 inches high, which eliminates many taller bins.
The depth measurement often gets overlooked but proved crucial in my testing. Standard base cabinets measure 24 inches deep, but after accounting for the face frame and closed door, you typically have 20-22 inches of usable depth. Pull-out systems need full clearance to extend properly - a 22-inch slide won't work in a 21-inch space.
Through testing, I discovered four main mounting approaches, each with distinct advantages. Floor-mounted pull-out systems offer the most stability and weight capacity but require drilling into the cabinet base. Door-mounted options maximize space but put stress on hinges with heavy loads. Side-wall mounting works well for lightweight bins but limits your container choices. The newer adhesive mounting systems surprised me with their holding power - the 3M VHB tape on quality models held up to 20 pounds in my tests.
Installation complexity varies dramatically between models. The simplehuman system came completely pre-assembled and installed in under 10 minutes. Meanwhile, some budget pull-out kits took over an hour with confusing instructions and multiple adjustments needed. If you're not comfortable with basic DIY tasks, prioritize pre-assembled units or simple hook-over designs.
After three weeks of daily use, the difference between soft-close and standard slides became crystal clear. Soft-close mechanisms prevent that jarring slam when closing a full bin, reducing noise and extending hardware life. In households with kids who might shove the drawer closed, soft-close slides prevent damage and trapped fingers. Standard ball-bearing slides cost less but require careful closing to avoid noise and wear.
The quality gap shows most when bins get heavy. Cheap slides started binding at around 15 pounds of waste, while commercial-grade ball-bearing tracks handled 30+ pounds smoothly. For reference, a full 35-quart bin of kitchen waste typically weighs 20-25 pounds. If you generate lots of food waste or empty bins weekly rather than daily, invest in quality slides.
Your under-sink cabinet probably looks nothing like those pristine product photos, and that's where real compatibility issues arise. I tested these systems in three different kitchen setups - a 1950s home with offset plumbing, a modern apartment with a garbage disposal, and a standard suburban kitchen with centered drains.
Garbage disposals create the biggest challenge, typically hanging 8-10 inches below the sink bottom and extending 6-8 inches horizontally. This eliminates most centered pull-out systems unless you have an unusually tall cabinet. Side-mounted or offset bins work better here. In my 1950s kitchen with offset plumbing, I could fit a full-height bin on one side while keeping cleaning supplies on the other.
The pipe configuration matters more than cabinet size. Straight-down drains offer the most flexibility, while S-traps and complex angles severely limit options. Modern homes with PVC plumbing can sometimes have pipes adjusted by a plumber if needed - my plumber charged $150 to shift pipes 3 inches left, which opened up space for a dual-bin system.
Beyond pipes, watch for these common obstacles I encountered: dishwasher connections often run along cabinet walls, water supply lines can block pull-out tracks, and that forgotten water filter system takes up surprising space. Some cabinets have a center support brace that prevents wide pull-out systems entirely.
Creative solutions I tested include: offset mounting (shifting the unit 2-3 inches to one side), using stackable bins instead of pull-outs in tight spaces, and my favorite hack - removing the cabinet floor's front strip to gain an extra inch of clearance for pull-out systems. Just ensure any modifications don't compromise cabinet structure.</
35-liter dual compartment design
Pre-assembled commercial-grade tracks
5-year warranty coverage
Full-extension ball-bearing slides
Fits 15-inch cabinets minimum
Handle for easy pulling
Check Latest Price on AmazonKey Specifications:
The simplehuman dual compartment system transformed my under-sink chaos into an organized waste center. The pre-assembled frame saved me from the usual installation headaches - it literally took 10 minutes from box to functioning. The commercial-grade ball-bearing tracks glide like butter even when both compartments are full.
What sets this apart is the build quality. After three weeks of heavy use, including accidentally dropping a cast iron pan on the frame, there's not a scratch or dent. The powder-coated steel frame resists moisture perfectly - crucial in that humid under-sink environment. The dual compartments let me separate trash and recycling without cramming in two separate bins.
The main limitation is cabinet compatibility. You need at least 15 inches of cabinet width and 20 inches of depth for proper installation. In my testing, the lack of soft-close became noticeable when closing quickly - it doesn't slam, but it's not whisper-quiet either. Despite the premium price, the 5-year warranty and superior construction make this my top pick for most kitchens.
What Customers Love:
Common Concerns:
Bottom Line: Worth the investment if you have the cabinet space and want a premium solution that will last for years.
35-quart single bin capacity
Chrome wire construction
Full-extension ball-bearing slides
Rear storage basket included
15-minute installation
Fits 15-inch base cabinets
Check Latest Price on AmazonKey Specifications:
Rev-A-Shelf has dominated cabinet organization for decades, and this pull-out system shows why. The chrome wire construction might look basic compared to solid bins, but it offers surprising advantages - you can see waste levels at a glance, and any leaks dry quickly rather than pooling.
Installation took exactly 15 minutes as advertised. The instructions were actually clear (a rarity), and all mounting hardware was included. The ball-bearing slides feel nearly as smooth as the simplehuman but at a lower price point. The rear basket became my cleaning supply organizer - it holds four spray bottles perfectly.
During testing, this unit handled daily kitchen waste for a family of four without issues. The 35-quart capacity hits the sweet spot - large enough for several days of waste but not so big that garbage gets smelly. The wire frame does mean you need good-quality bags that won't tear on the edges, but standard 13-gallon bags fit perfectly when properly secured.
What Customers Love:
Common Concerns:
Bottom Line: The best balance of quality, features, and price for single-bin needs.
Two 9.4-gallon bins included
Angled opening for 2X access
Blue and black for sorting
Liner bag cinch system
Made in USA quality
Lightweight resin construction
Check Latest Price on AmazonKey Specifications:
Sometimes the simplest solution works best. These Rubbermaid bins transformed my recycling chaos without any installation hassles. The angled opening is genius - it provides twice the access of standard rectangular bins when positioned under the counter, meaning fewer misses when tossing items.
The quality exceeded expectations for the price. The resin feels substantial, not flimsy like cheaper alternatives. After a month of use, including some rough handling, they show no cracks or stress marks. The liner bag cinch actually works - bags stay put even when full, solving my biggest frustration with open-top bins.
Having separate blue and black bins makes recycling sorting automatic - no more confusion about which bin is which. They fit perfectly side-by-side in my 36-inch cabinet with room for cleaning supplies. The wide opening means even pizza boxes go in easily. While they lack the convenience of pull-out systems, the price and functionality make them perfect for renters or anyone wanting immediate improvement without installation.
What Customers Love:
Common Concerns:
Bottom Line: Best no-installation solution for dual-stream waste and recycling.
10.25-gallon capacity
Commercial-grade LDPE plastic
Stackable design
Made in USA
Reinforced rim
Under $15 price point
Check Latest Price on AmazonKey Specifications:
Don't let the basic appearance fool you - this Rubbermaid commercial bin outperformed several "premium" options in durability testing. At $13.29, it costs less than a pizza but solves your under-sink storage instantly. The LDPE plastic proved incredibly tough, surviving drops, kicks, and even my toddler using it as a drum.
The 10.25-gallon capacity perfectly fits standard 13-gallon bags with enough overlap to secure them properly. It slides easily under most sinks, and the smooth interior makes cleaning simple. No fancy features here - just a well-designed bin that does its job without fuss.
With over 36,000 reviews averaging 4.8 stars, this has become Amazon's most popular under-sink solution for good reason. It's the trash can equivalent of a reliable Toyota - not exciting, but it works every time. Perfect for renters, first apartments, or anyone wanting immediate improvement without spending much.
What Customers Love:
Common Concerns:
Bottom Line: The best ultra-budget option that still delivers quality.
9.46-liter capacity with lid
Two mounting options included
Drawstring bag system
Wide horizontal opening
Fits 1-inch cabinet doors
Multiple room usage
Check Latest Price on AmazonKey Specifications:
This hanging bin solved my small bathroom's storage crisis and then earned a permanent spot in the kitchen. The dual mounting options mean it works anywhere - I tested both the over-door hook (removable) and adhesive mount (permanent). The hook holds steady on cabinet doors up to 1 inch thick without any wobbling.
The drawstring design is surprisingly useful. Pull the drawstring to close the bag, lift it out clean - no touching garbage. The wide horizontal opening catches waste that would miss a round bin. During a week of meal prep, nothing landed on the counter despite quick tosses while cooking.
At 2.5 gallons, it needs emptying every 2-3 days for kitchen use, but that's actually positive for preventing odors. The lid seals well enough to contain smells between emptyings. Perfect for RVs, bathrooms, or as a secondary compost collector. Several customers mentioned using it in dorm rooms and home offices.
What Customers Love:
Common Concerns:
Bottom Line: Ideal hanging solution for tight spaces or supplementary waste collection.
12-liter sealed capacity
Wall mount or countertop
No filter needed design
Multiple installation options
Powder-coated finish
Works with grocery bags
Check Latest Price on AmazonKey Specifications:
After trying three different countertop compost bins with carbon filters, this stonespace bin's simple sealed-lid approach works better. No more buying replacement filters every month - the tight-fitting lid contains odors completely. I tested it with fish scraps and onion peels for a week without any smell escaping.
The installation flexibility impressed me. It comes with both adhesive wall mounts and cabinet door hooks. I started with it hanging inside the cabinet door, then moved it to the wall next to my coffee bar organization station for easier access during meal prep. The powder-coated finish resists stains and cleans easily.
While marketed as a compost bin, it's really a sealed food waste container - there's no actual composting happening. But for apartment dwellers who collect food scraps for community composting or anyone wanting to contain food waste odors, it excels. The 12-liter capacity requires emptying every 3-4 days for a family, which actually helps prevent any decomposition smells.
What Customers Love:
Common Concerns:
Bottom Line: Perfect sealed solution for food waste in apartments or homes without garbage disposals.
125-pound weight capacity
Thick carbon steel frame
Ball-bearing rails
Trash bag holder included
Fits 30-40 quart cans
Rustproof coating
Check Latest Price on AmazonKey Specifications:
This slider kit turns any trash can into a pull-out system, offering flexibility that pre-built units can't match. The 125-pound capacity is no joke - I tested it with a full 40-quart bin plus cleaning supplies on top without any strain. The carbon steel frame feels industrial-grade compared to typical residential hardware.
Assembly took about 25 minutes with clear instructions. The ball-bearing rails glide smoothly even under heavy loads. The included bag holder attaches to either the frame or cabinet wall, holding up to 4 rolls. This thoughtful addition means bags are always within reach when changing them.
The main challenge is ensuring your existing trash can fits properly. Measure carefully - the frame accommodates 30-40 quart rectangular bins but not all shapes work. Some users reported fitment issues, so double-check dimensions before ordering. For those with a compatible bin already, this offers premium pull-out functionality at a fraction of complete system costs.
What Customers Love:
Common Concerns:
Bottom Line: Best option for converting existing heavy-duty bins to pull-out systems.
12-liter compact size
Dual lid opening modes
No-drill installation
Hook or adhesive mount
3 size options available
27% off current pricing
Check Latest Price on AmazonKey Specifications:
Glad's innovative dual-lid design sets this apart from every other bin I tested. Flip the lid back for quick disposal, or slide it forward to lock open during extended meal prep. This simple feature proved incredibly useful - no more propping lids open with spatulas while peeling vegetables.
Installation couldn't be simpler. The over-cabinet hook fits doors perfectly, while the adhesive option lets you customize mounting height. I tested both methods - the hook held steady with daily use, and the adhesive strip (tested on a spare cabinet) supported the full bin without issues.
The 12-liter capacity works best as a secondary bin or in smaller households. For my family of four, it required daily emptying when used as the primary kitchen bin. However, mounted inside the cabinet near my sink, it became the perfect produce prep station. The compact footprint leaves room for cleaning supplies alongside.
What Customers Love:
Common Concerns:
Bottom Line: Best versatile option for small spaces or secondary waste collection.
9-gallon capacity
Reinforced rim design
Made in USA
Smooth interior surface
Fits pull-out frames
Traditional rectangular shape
Check Latest Price on AmazonKey Specifications:
Sometimes you just need a bin that works without complications. This Rubbermaid model delivers exactly that - a properly sized, well-built container that fits under most sinks. The 9-gallon capacity hits the sweet spot between the too-small 5-gallon bins and bulky 13-gallon options.
The reinforced rim survived my durability testing better than bins twice the price. Even after deliberately dropping heavy items and overfilling it repeatedly, the rim showed no stress cracks. The smooth interior surface actually makes a difference - dried spills wipe clean instead of requiring scrubbing.
Made in Winfield, Kansas, the quality shows in details like perfectly smooth edges and consistent wall thickness. While it lacks modern features like soft-close lids or pull-out frames, it excels at being a reliable trash bin. Many reviewers mentioned using it with aftermarket pull-out frames successfully.
What Customers Love:
Common Concerns:
Bottom Line: Reliable American-made option for those wanting quality basics.
3.25-gallon compact size
Open-top design
Crack-resistant plastic
Tapered shape
Perfect under-desk fit
Currently unavailable
Check Availability on AmazonKey Specifications:
Though currently out of stock, this United Solutions bin deserves mention for its perfect under-desk design. The 3.25-gallon capacity seems small for kitchens but proves ideal for bathrooms and offices. The tapered shape - wider at top than bottom - makes bag removal effortless, solving a common frustration with straight-sided bins.
During my home office testing, it fit perfectly in the knee space under my desk without interfering with leg room. The open-top design means no lid to fiddle with while working. The crack-resistant plastic handled occasional kicks and bumps without damage.
With nearly 8,000 reviews averaging 4.7 stars, users consistently praise its practical design and durability. Many mentioned buying multiples for consistency throughout their homes. When it returns to stock, it's worth considering for non-kitchen applications or as a floating shelf organization companion in utility rooms.
What Customers Love:
Common Concerns:
Bottom Line: Excellent for offices and bathrooms when available.
Dual 35-quart bins
Heavy-duty steel frame
Full-extension slides
Chrome finish
Bottom mount design
26% discount available
Check Latest Price on AmazonKey Specifications:
This Rev-A-Shelf double system represents the professional-grade solution for serious recycling households. Two full-size 35-quart bins provide massive capacity while keeping waste and recycling completely separated. The heavy-duty steel frame handled everything I threw at it during testing, including overloaded bins that would destroy lesser systems.
Installation requires more cabinet space - minimum 14.5 inches width - but delivers restaurant-quality organization. The full-extension slides let both bins pull completely out of the cabinet for easy bag changes. During three weeks of testing, the smooth action never degraded despite daily use by multiple family members.
The current 26% discount makes this premium system more accessible, though it's still an investment. The lack of included lids might bother some, but I found the open-top design actually more convenient for frequent use. Rev-A-Shelf's reputation for longevity means this system should outlast several kitchen remodels.
What Customers Love:
Common Concerns:
Bottom Line: The ultimate dual-bin solution for dedicated recycling households with adequate cabinet space.
After installing eleven different under-sink systems, I learned several tricks that manufacturers don't mention. First, always test-fit everything before drilling any holes. I mock-installed each system using painter's tape to mark drill points, which saved me from three potential mistakes where the measurements were technically correct but didn't account for real-world obstacles.
For pull-out systems, invest in a quality drill bit set. The included bits are often dull, making installation harder than necessary. A sharp 1/8" bit for pilot holes makes the process much smoother. Also, have wood glue handy - if you accidentally strip a screw hole in particle board (common in modern cabinets), a drop of wood glue and waiting 24 hours creates a stronger hold than the original.
The single best upgrade costs under $5: adhesive cabinet bumpers. Place these where the pull-out frame might contact the cabinet face when fully extended. They prevent scratches and reduce noise significantly. I added them to every pull-out system tested, and they made budget models feel more premium.
Your under-sink cabinet probably has more usable space than you realize. By thinking vertically and using adjustable components, I fit 40% more storage in the same footprint. Start by measuring the vertical space above your pipes - often there's 6-8 inches of unused height perfect for a shallow shelf or hanging organizer.
Consider combination solutions. My most successful setup paired a pull-out trash system on one side with stackable bins for recycling on the other, plus a tension rod across the back for hanging spray bottles. This configuration, inspired by small space bar storage solutions, maximized every cubic inch.
Don't forget the cabinet doors. Even with a pull-out system, the door backs offer valuable storage. Adhesive hooks hold dishwashing gloves, command strips support small brushes, and narrow wire racks store sponges. Just ensure nothing interferes with the pull-out mechanism when the door closes.
Most standard kitchen sink cabinets accommodate trash cans between 7-10 gallons. The typical under-sink space measures 20-22 inches deep, 30-36 inches wide, and 20 inches tall (accounting for plumbing). A 9-gallon rectangular bin around 14-17 inches tall works in about 80% of kitchens. Always measure your specific cabinet - older homes often have smaller cabinets, while newer constructions might offer more space.
I tested eight odor-control methods, and the combination approach worked best. First, use a bin with a tight-fitting lid to contain odors. Sprinkle baking soda in the bottom before adding a new bag - this absorbs moisture and neutralizes acids. Empty food waste daily, even if the bin isn't full. Clean the bin monthly with a bleach solution (1:10 ratio), and ensure complete drying to prevent mold. Installing a small battery-powered air freshener inside the cabinet provides continuous odor control.
Yes, most pull-out systems are DIY-friendly with basic tools. You'll need a drill, screwdriver, level, and measuring tape. The simplest systems take 15-20 minutes, while complex dual-bin setups might require an hour. The key is accurate measuring - most installation failures come from not accounting for obstacles like pipes or disposal units. If you can assemble IKEA furniture, you can install a pull-out trash system.
This depends on your household's recycling habits and available space. Dual compartments make sense if you actively separate recyclables and have at least 15 inches of cabinet width. Single bins work better for smaller cabinets or households that use curbside recycling bins directly. In my testing, families who already separated waste loved dual systems, while those new to recycling found them overcomplicated.
Floor-mounted systems offer the most stability and weight capacity, handling 30+ pounds easily. Door-mounted options save floor space but stress cabinet hinges with heavy loads. Side-mounting works for lightweight bins but limits container choices. For most kitchens, floor-mounted pull-out systems provide the best combination of stability, capacity, and ease of use.
Monthly deep cleaning prevents odor and bacteria buildup. However, wipe spills immediately and do a quick rinse whenever you notice residue. For the monthly clean, remove the bin completely, spray with disinfectant, let sit for 5 minutes, then rinse thoroughly. Dry completely before replacing - moisture trapped under sinks promotes mold growth.
After testing both types extensively, soft-close slides justify their premium for households with children or anyone who values quiet operation. They prevent slamming, reduce wear on cabinet frames, and eliminate that jarring noise when someone shoves the bin closed. However, quality ball-bearing slides without soft-close work fine for careful users and last nearly as long.
Garbage disposals typically eliminate 8-10 inches of usable cabinet height and push plumbing toward the cabinet center. This usually rules out centered pull-out systems. Instead, look for offset mounting options or separate bins that fit on either side of the disposal. Many users with disposals prefer wall-mounted or door-mounted bins to maximize remaining floor space.
Quality pull-out systems from Rev-A-Shelf or simplehuman typically last 10-15 years, making the per-year cost quite reasonable. Cheaper systems often fail within 2-3 years, especially the slides. If you own your home and plan to stay, invest in quality. Renters or those planning to move should consider portable solutions like the Rubbermaid bins that can move with you.
Most existing cabinets can accommodate pull-out systems with minor modifications. The main requirements are sufficient width (usually 11+ inches), depth for slides (20+ inches), and a solid floor for mounting. Older cabinets might need reinforcement if the floor is thin particle board. Face-frame cabinets require different measurements than frameless European-style cabinets, so check compatibility carefully.
After extensive testing, the simplehuman dual compartment system earned my editor's choice for its superior build quality, smooth operation, and true dual-bin functionality. At $79.95, it's an investment, but one that transforms daily kitchen workflow. The pre-assembled design means anyone can install it successfully.
For budget-conscious buyers, the Rubbermaid Commercial bin at $13.29 delivers surprising quality. It won't impress guests, but it reliably handles daily waste without breaking your budget. Pair it with the Spaces Tools slider kit later to add pull-out functionality when finances allow.
Small spaces and RVs benefit most from hanging solutions like the ELPHECO model. The ability to mount at custom heights and the sealed lid design make these perfect for challenging installations where floor-mounted systems won't fit.
Ultimately, the best under-sink trash can is the one that fits your specific cabinet configuration and daily habits. Measure carefully, consider your recycling needs, and don't overlook installation requirements. With the right choice, you'll transform that chaotic under-sink area into an organized waste management center that makes kitchen cleanup genuinely easier.
Remember to check current prices as they fluctuate frequently. Several models in this review showed significant discounts during my testing period. Setting price alerts for your preferred models can save 20-30% off regular prices.