The Frightful Jack-O'-Lantern in Fisch's Halloween event is obtained by fishing in any body of water during FischFright 2025, then either using a Frightful Relic on your rod for a 10% mutation chance or appraising a regular Jack-O'-Lantern at the FischFright Appraiser NPC. This essential item is required for the Headless Horseman quest and can […]